Why? I don't know where you are coming from, but the world is a big place and there are lots of nice places to go. Granted, there are visa / immigration issues in plenty of countries apart from the US as well, but frankly for decades now the US has been on the decline in every measure of livability: health care, education, incomes, leisure time, commute time, etc, etc. About the only thing the US nominally leads in is a vague notion that you can make more money here than in other countries, but even that is subjective relative to the cost of living and quality of life.
Literal genocide is now being practiced at the border.
I'm not sure what part of this comparison is outrageous to you. The material conditions of reality have changed: now we are at a point where these comparisons are apt.
Citation please? The only thing I've heard alleged that would even be close is the woman who had her uterus removed as part of a cancer treatment...
> Accused hospital says just two hysterectomies were performed there (washingtonpost.com)
>Hospital for ICE accused of mass hysterectomies says it only carried out 2 (businessinsider.com)
>No evidence of sterilization of migrant Mexican women, says Mexican minister (reuters.com)
Based on the headlines, I guess it's safe to say that there there isn't a genocide going on?
Specifically, it is very surprising that you're using the hospital's own press release to conclude that no injustice happens on their premises.
Also, people entering from the Mexican border are not all Mexican. Many come from countries further south.
If someone's actually attempting genocide and all they can manage is a few thousand sterilizations, they should be fired for incompetence, too! (Plus, you know, genocide)
Further, is there any evidence that you would be willing to accept that genocide is not happening here? Any source that you'd be willing to commit to accepting?
> And I'm ashamed that you're describing a number of hysterectomies that at most, using laughably high estimates, could number in the thousands, as genocide
Two things here:
1. the number of hysterectomies that a single doctor could perform over, say, 4 years is ~10,000 (at 10/day). That's an extreme case, and relies on almost everything being geared towards rate of surgeries, and so works as an upper bound for what was alleged. (That there was a doctor purposefully sterilizing ICE detainees)
2. 10k sterilizations is not genocide. It would be monstrous, but it's at least 100x too few to count as that IMO given the ~10m illegal immigrants already residing within the US.
> (Which would be horrible! But also leave enough evidence that it would clearly not be one or two cases)
"Which would be horrible!" should require no explanation. The second point here is that if a doctor was somehow able to perform thousands of hysterectomies every year, there would be mountains of evidence for that, and conservatively tens of victims willing to speak up and go to the press, even if only 1% were willing and able.
> If someone's actually attempting genocide and all they can manage is a few thousand sterilizations, they should be fired for incompetence, too! (Plus, you know, genocide)
If this was being orchestrated by someone at ICE somehow, I would expect there to be more "effective" and less likely to be exposed methods of sterilization available to a determined administrator. Thus, two reasons to fire them - one is that they're an utter piece of shit for attempting genocide, and the second is that they're fucking incompetent. A sort of "awful taste AND awful execution" scenario.
> Further, is there any evidence that you would be willing to accept that genocide is not happening here? Any source that you'd be willing to commit to accepting?
This should also be self explanatory. Is there a news source that you would trust if it said that there was no evidence of genocide here? If MSNBC or the NY Times said that this was all a hoax, would you accept that? Or the governments of Guatemala, Honduras, etc? I ask this because you've rejected denials from ICE, the hospital, and the Mexican government - what other sources do you expect to be reliable?
If your belief isn't falsifiable, then I know not to expect any engagement from you.
> Please, I implore you, read your comment again. It is so callous as to be near-sociopathic. Yours is very much not a healthy view into morality.
I've clarified everything there that I think might have been unclear. Is it less sociopathic to you now?
This misses the context behind the relocations. In the case of the holocaust, they were legally living there before being relocated. In the case of undocumented immigrants, they illegally moved there, and are now being moved back.
Removing people from their homes is a little different from sending them back home when they enter your country illegally.
> Literal genocide is now being practiced at the border.
No, it isn’t.
> Godwin's law itself can be abused as a distraction, diversion or even as censorship, fallaciously miscasting an opponent's argument as hyperbole when the comparisons made by the argument are actually appropriate. Mike Godwin himself has also criticized the overapplication of Godwin's law, claiming it does not articulate a fallacy; it is instead framed as a memetic tool to reduce the incidence of inappropriate, hyperbolic comparisons. [...]
> In December 2015, Godwin commented on the Nazi and fascist comparisons being made by several articles about Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump, saying: "If you're thoughtful about it and show some real awareness of history, go ahead and refer to Hitler when you talk about Trump, or any other politician." [...]
> In June, 2018, Godwin wrote an opinion piece in the Los Angeles Times which denied the need to update or amend the rule, and which rejects the idea that whoever invokes Godwin's Law has lost their argument, and which argues that appropriate application of the rule "should function less as a conversation ender and more as a conversation starter". [...]
> In June 2019, after Chris Hayes invoked Godwin's Law in a discussion of whether it was appropriate to call the United States's refugee detention centers "concentration camps", Godwin explicitly stated his belief that the term "concentration camps" was appropriate.