Re:Uber Wasted $2.5B on Self-Driving Cars
by jimrandomh on Monday September 28, 2020 @08:56PM
(#24623067)
Not really. Rail in the US is spectacularly expensive; look up a few recent rail projects with dollar figures attached, they're billions of dollars each. That's the same order of magnitude as the cost of an entire self-driving research program (Waymo has taken $3B of investment, according to its Wikipedia page), which, if successful, would scale quickly and easily to the entire world.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Uber Wasted $2.5B on Self-Driving Cars
by jcranmer on Monday September 28, 2020 @09:24PM
(#24623260)
Alon Levy has put together a database on transit costs: https://transitcosts.com/
The important metric isn't the cost of the project, it's the cost per km (or mile, if you prefer). The construction costs for NYC in particularly are unjustifiably obscene--it's really on the level of "fire everyone involved and make the new hires go on a world tour of transit system agencies to learn how they do cost control before they do anything."
Re:Uber Wasted $2.5B on Self-Driving Cars
by xvilka on Monday September 28, 2020 @09:03PM
(#24623123)
If the US companies can't do it just hire Chinese or Japanese ones who have enormous experience to build the infrastructure way cheaper.
Re:Uber Wasted $2.5B on Self-Driving Cars
by jcranmer on Monday September 28, 2020 @09:26PM
(#24623277)
China and Japan aren't exactly low-cost construction countries. Actually, they're among the highest-cost non-Anglosphere countries (which are perhaps best labeled "stratospheric-cost" countries). Instead, you want to look to places like Spain, Italy, Sweden, or South Korea as low-cost countries.
Re:Uber Wasted $2.5B on Self-Driving Cars
by TheMblabla on Monday September 28, 2020 @09:31PM
(#24623302)
Their costs are lower because their land aquisition costs are lower. The problem isn't the tech it's the regulations/property rights.
Re:Uber Wasted $2.5B on Self-Driving Cars
by cycrutchfield on Monday September 28, 2020 @09:13PM
(#24623195)
Yeah, just bulldoze some houses and apartment blocks, so easy to build rail lines. Why didn’t anybody else try this?
Re:Uber Wasted $2.5B on Self-Driving Cars
by FreakyT on Monday September 28, 2020 @09:08PM
(#24623154)
Exactly this -- plenty of other countries have figured out how to build rail systems without massive cost overruns.
Re:Uber Wasted $2.5B on Self-Driving Cars
by rrrrrrrrrrrryan on Monday September 28, 2020 @10:04PM
(#24623508)
The expensive part is addressing all the local regulations and acquiring land.
Human rights (and property rights) can be expensive.