News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dropbox Lack of Security by StavrosK on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @07:00AM (#2462225)
As others said, #1 is false. You can look at your data whenever you want without letting others do the same, even if they have access to the data. That's what asymmetric (or even symmetric) cryptography does.

Apart from that, did anyone ever think Dropbox was completely secure? The mere fact that they perform deduplication, which is not possible if they can't read your data, should have tipped people off to it. Not to mention showing the files in the web client, sharing, etc.

Re:Dropbox Lack of Security by T-hawk on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @09:56AM (#2462598)
> The mere fact that they perform deduplication, which is not possible if they can't read your data

It is possible because it's client-server. When a new file appears in the Dropbox folder, the Dropbox client calculates a hash of it and checks if that hash already exists with Dropbox's server-side storage. If not, then the file is uploaded and stored encrypted. You do have to trust that the Dropbox client is actually doing what it claims to do, that it isn't uploading with no or trivial encryption (like an xor or something.)

Re:Dropbox Lack of Security by StavrosK on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @10:00AM (#2462611)
And what happens when the file that matches the hash isn't yours?
Re:Dropbox Lack of Security by dhimes on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @08:52AM (#2462449)
I don't use Dropbox so I recently learned that they performed data deduplication. For me this is still a breaking story.