News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by atoav on Monday September 28, 2020 @07:22AM (#24615436)
Well well. My girlfriends oldest brother died in what was a wave of cancer infant deaths that strangely coincides with the fallout of Chernobyl's radioactive cloud.

Her other brother came to the world deformed, which again happened to more mothers than hers. In my school class (~30 kids) alone there were 4 kids who had deformations or other mutations that affected their life's negatively (for those who still live: to this day). All of them were born in the years after the fallout.

In my region you are still adviced not to eat certain mushrooms or the meat of boars.

Not to speak that one death and one deformed child that needs life long attention does something to the families tho whom such things happen.

Of course all of it is incredibly hard to attribute this to Chernobyl, but the region which got the brink of the radioactive rain (southern Bavaria, southern Austria) had the most of such cases to such a degree that the doctors noticed it.

That being said: of course a lot improved after Chernobyl in terms of reactor safety. But nuclear is still a business, where a (not insignificant) part of the costs linked to waste and potential catastrophes aren't carried by those who earn the money.

So whether nuclear really is affordable depends on how you do the accounting — how much you get the public, the environment and by future generations to carry for free.

E.g. how much does it cost to store 1 kg of nuclear waste safely for 10 000 years? Is that cost prized into the cost of the produced electricity or do we expect future generations to carry it even after all uranium has been burned?

Please convince me that nuclear isn't a Ponzi-scheme on the future generations.

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by Lazare on Monday September 28, 2020 @10:53AM (#24617260)
> My girlfriends oldest brother died in what was a wave of cancer infant deaths [..]

That's horrible, and I don't want to diminish it in any way. Nuclear power has killed many people, and impacted many more others negatively. Thousands, certainly, possibly tens of thousands. Some (very disputed) estimates for Chernobyl range as high as hundreds of thousands of premature deaths. Each of those is a unique tragedy.

On the other hand, fossil fuels kills thousands of people per day. There's no free lunch here. Deactivating a nuclear power plant and then having to rely on more coal than otherwise costs actual lives.

You can point to some actual victims of Chernobyl, so it feels realer to you, but the victims of fossil fuels are all around you too, and outnumber them enormously.

> of course a lot improved after Chernobyl

Quite true, but again, coal is hundreds of times more deadly than nuclear even if you include Chernobyl in the statistics. If you assume things have gotten better since then, then the deck is even more overwhelmingly stacked in favour of the safety of nuclear power.

To be clear: Even if you assume that nuclear power is a horrifying thing that will send a plume of radioactive ash across Europe every few decades causing birth defects and death, it still beats coal on safety. Of course, nobody thinks modern nuclear power plants are remotely that dangerous...and yet we're still building new coal plants, even today.

Oh, and not that it matter hugely, but:

> E.g. how much does it cost to store 1 kg of nuclear waste safely for 10 000 years?

So low it rounds to zero. I'm sceptical about the true unsubsidised costs of nuclear power, but waste storage isn't a particularly hard (or expensive) problem.

On the other hand, flip it around; what's the cost to store 1 kg of the radioactive waste safely? Wait, we can't store it safely; by the design of the plant it emits it straight into the atmosphere.

> Please convince me that nuclear isn't a Ponzi-scheme on the future generations.

The real question is whether it's affordable for current generations. It's clearly just fine for future generations.

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by dv_dt on Monday September 28, 2020 @12:44PM (#24618571)
Compare vs renewables not coal.
Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by necheffa on Monday September 28, 2020 @12:57PM (#24618724)
Renewables are not a silver bullet either. There are plenty of nasty things that go into building batteries and solar panels with no where near the attention to safely disposing them. Plus, renewables just can't handle baseload and load follow the way fossil or nuclear can.
Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by dv_dt on Monday September 28, 2020 @02:39PM (#24619907)
Battery storage follows load much faster than fossil, and nuclear can't follow at all.
Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by VBprogrammer on Monday September 28, 2020 @03:31PM (#24620389)
Wrong on nuclear. They operate in load following in France just fine.
Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by dv_dt on Monday September 28, 2020 @06:01PM (#24621691)
Until it gets too hot and they have to ironically shut down the plants during heat waves.
Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by VBprogrammer on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @04:13AM (#24625246)
The same would be true of any thermoelectric power station. They all need cooling of the condenser.
Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by dv_dt on Tuesday October 06, 2020 @04:02PM (#24701750)
But not true of photovoltaic or wind power stations...
Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by Lazare on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @04:59AM (#24625432)
We're still building coal power plants right now. See, eg, "Japan Races to Build New Coal-Burning Power Plants" from Feb of this year (https://www.nytimes.com/2020/02/03/climate/japan-coal-fukush...).

In many places, what replaced nuclear power plants we decommission or choose not to build is not renewables, so that's by no means the only relevant comparison.

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by gtsteve on Monday September 28, 2020 @08:09AM (#24615726)
> of course a lot improved after Chernobyl in terms of reactor safety

My understanding is that Chernobyl was caused by an experiment that went wrong due to errors in following processes correctly.

I would assume that most reactors just make electricity, and outside of smaller reactors used for research they aren't used for experiments. Is that correct?

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by dboreham on Monday September 28, 2020 @08:20AM (#24615807)
Not an expert but my understanding is that you are largely incorrect. The "experiment" was a test the facility had to pass (dark station shutdown) in order to be certified safe. The site's primary function was to generate electricity. Secondary function to create weapons material precursors. That humans had to follow processes in order to avoid contaminating large parts of Europe is a fundamental failing.
Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by speeder on Monday September 28, 2020 @08:39AM (#24615981)
Kinda.

Dark Station shutdown is still a problem in some senses.

They were indeed, doing an experiment, not just to pass a certification, but they were testing a theory, that in fact makes perfect sense, just the execution of the test was extremely crap.

The problem: when the power grid fails, there is no power to keep the coolant system pumps working, thus might cause a meltdown.

Chernobyl solution: attempt to improve the turbine designs so they can keep generating power using their own inertia until the diesel generators are online.

Chernobyl first failed attempts: improvements were not enough, the idea DID worked, but the turbines stopped spinning too early.

Chernobyl last attempt: power usage in the day of the test was unusually high, not only the test was delayed but the reactor had to produce more power than usual, when the test finally came, the procedures of the test weren't followed properly, the crew that did the test didn't knew how to do it, and after they pushed the reactor parameters to values outside the design limits, the computer attempted to fight back, so they disabled the safety features of the computer and tried to control the situation manually, doing things the computer was requesting them to NOT do.

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by neffy on Monday September 28, 2020 @08:48AM (#24616054)
No, there was a design flaw in the reactor, that caused the emergency shutdown procedure to trigger a runaway reaction.