News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by roenxi on Monday September 28, 2020 @03:23AM (#24613889)
Those are held to a much lower standard. I've seen people on HN seriously argue that we need to isolate nuclear waste from the biosphere for multiple generations, including contingencies for the collapse of English as a comprehensible language.

What is the plan to isolate the poisonous meals in a solar panel for multiple generations? There isn't one. It just goes in landfill, I expect with relatively little concern for if it is setting up the next Flint, Michigan scenario.

I doubt any form of energy would be economic if it was held to the same standards as Nuclear. It is perfectly safe, has proved itself to be perfectly safe now that we have 50 years of evidence and then the operators have to spend however much it takes to make it safer than that. This impossible task turns out to be hellishly expensive.

There are literally 2 or 3 stories where there was a bad meltdown, and even then the damage seems to be comparable to having used coal over the same period of time. Worst-case scenario with 40 year old reactor designs is comparable to business as usual, and people start arguing over if that is safe enough.

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by mantap on Monday September 28, 2020 @04:06AM (#24614190)
Radioactive material is treated differently because it is dangerous at a distance. You don't need to eat it or even touch it. Simply standing close enough to it is enough to be harmful. It's just not comparable to anything in a solar panel.

After decommissioning a solar farm, at worst the soil might not be suitable for farming but nobody would complain about building a house there. For the same to be true of a nuclear plant a very expensive decommissioning process must be completed.

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by VBprogrammer on Monday September 28, 2020 @04:33AM (#24614352)
The second hand market for decommissioned panels is now strong enough that it has gotten hard to source them by the container load.

This used to be a great way of sourcing solar panels for off grid applications where a small drop in efficiency was totally offset by the low cost.

I think we can also safely assume used lithium batteries will similarly remain in high demand.

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by roenxi on Monday September 28, 2020 @05:27AM (#24614719)
> Radioactive material is treated differently because it is dangerous at a distance. You don't need to eat it or even touch it. Simply standing close enough to it is enough to be harmful. It's just not comparable to anything in a solar panel.

I don't think that is true, the article cites that the majority of the bad cancer cases from Chernobyl were caused by ingestion of tainted milk.

Besides, the core of that argument there is you have no evidence ergo there is no problem. That isn't a good argument. There are some horrific substances used in industrial processes (like, eg, the production of solar panels). Just because you want to think about them in nuclear but not elsewhere doesn't mean the problems go away. Industrial waste is industrial waste; humanity has been ignoring this stuff for millennia. It is no reason to block something as measurably environmentally positive as nuclear. The numbers suggest nuclear does less harm.

We should be holding all the options to the same safety standards.

> After decommissioning a solar farm, at worst the soil might not be suitable for farming but nobody would complain about building a house there. For the same to be true of a nuclear plant a very expensive decommissioning process must be completed.

Don't build a house there then. Incidentally it'd be a prime spot for a new nuclear plant.

These things are perfectly safe for people to work in, the issue is highly localised. The area of a plant is small. And, again, by the numbers a solar panel farm is going to sterilise a larger area of land. The fact that in theory it could be used doesn't change the fact it is going to be unusable by virtue of being covered in solar panels.

Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by bregma on Monday September 28, 2020 @07:36AM (#24615523)
Just wait until people find out how lithium batteries are an incredibly toxic fire hazard with incredibly expensive externalities involved in their production and disposal. At least people haven't been stockpiling nuclear fuel pellets in their homes and sending them to their local landfill.
Re:Nuclear power: Are we too anxious about the risks of radi... by kohlerm on Monday September 28, 2020 @06:57AM (#24615291)
What are you doing with the waste? Coal being as dangerous is no argument, which also should not use coal. Also suing Coal has a different probability distribution. Coal power plants do not blow up like Nuclear power plants do. Even if they would do the consequences would be much smaller. How do you measure BTW lost area of the Chernobyl accident? You IMHO just cannot count only how many people died (which is difficult enough).