News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Peter Thiel Is Wrong About Higher Education (It’s Worse T... by WalterBright on Monday April 18, 2011 @05:35PM (#2460806)
I've seen very, very few people able to learn calculus outside of a school system. Most will just go to elaborate lengths to avoid using calculus and justify why they don't need to learn it.
Re:Peter Thiel Is Wrong About Higher Education (It’s Worse T... by kragen on Monday April 18, 2011 @09:01PM (#2461309)
I did, more or less, but I was pretty motivated. If I hadn't been so strongly motivated, I wouldn't have been able to do it at all. As it was, I switched to taking calculus classes at the first opportunity.

The funny thing is, though, I did a lot better on the AP exam than the kids who did take a calculus class, the same class I would have taken if I'd finished the prerequisite class in time. And, after a semester of taking it in a class, I'd pretty much lost interest.

("more or less": This was in high school. I failed to put in much time on it during the summer, since I was busy traveling to Japan and falling in love, so I signed up for "study hall" as an elective, and spent that time studying calculus with a textbook. The structured time without much distraction was very helpful in making it through enough of the book to do well on the exam.)

What are some other topics that you very rarely see people learn other than by schooling? Machine learning, physics, surgery?

Re:Peter Thiel Is Wrong About Higher Education (It’s Worse T... by WalterBright on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @02:21PM (#2463598)
High school calculus barely scratches the surface of what calculus is, though to be sure, I've only personally encountered one person who got that far with calculus without school.
Re:Peter Thiel Is Wrong About Higher Education (It’s Worse T... by kragen on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @03:45PM (#2463930)
Yes, unfortunately I didn't really get anywhere after my university vector calculus course. Didn't even take diff-eqs.
Re:Peter Thiel Is Wrong About Higher Education (It’s Worse T... by Dn_Ab on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @03:47PM (#2463939)
I don't believe it needs to be that way. Why was one of my personal heroes, George Green able to do what he did?

Through Thomson, Maxwell, and others, the general mathematical theory of potential developed by an obscure, self-taught miller's son would lead to the mathematical theories of electricity underlying twentieth-century industry.

http://www-history.mcs.st-andrews.ac.uk/Biographies/Green.ht... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Green

I think I have learned myself a decent amount of calculus.I suggest anyone interested in self learning calculus to to try Infinitesimal Analysis first as its more intuitive. Epsilon delta becomes easier after. And for differential calculus, consider implementing a Higher Order Multivariate Automatic Differentiator able to deal with Jacobians and Hessians efficiently. That hands on learning helps a lot.

Re:Peter Thiel Is Wrong About Higher Education (It’s Worse T... by compuguy on Monday April 18, 2011 @09:16PM (#2461339)
The big issue in math in high school and higher universities, is the excessive use of rote memory. You do not need to memorize, word for word, multiple proofs, in order to understand and apply knowledge you learn in a mathematics class. The same goes to mathematical formulas.
Re:Peter Thiel Is Wrong About Higher Education (It’s Worse T... by Tycho on Monday April 18, 2011 @06:11PM (#2460947)
Fair enough. What examples did you have in mind of people trying to avoid the use of calculus (where it would be the best solution)?
Re:Peter Thiel Is Wrong About Higher Education (It’s Worse T... by bartonfink on Monday April 18, 2011 @07:28PM (#2461149)
I don't know that people are avoiding the use of calculus where it's appropriate. Rather, they believe that they will never encounter a situation where calculus is the appropriate tool and thus claim that they don't need to learn it.

It's a shame, because understanding differentiation and integration has had a tremendous impact on the way I think. It literally was a gamechanger for me, and it's worth it even though I only use it in thought exercises now.

Re:Peter Thiel Is Wrong About Higher Education (It’s Worse T... by WalterBright on Tuesday April 19, 2011 @02:27PM (#2463630)
They guessed at the answer (these are people doing mechanical and electronic designs). They'd test the design, and it would not work. They'd guess again, test, did not work. Quite a bit of time and money would be wasted, whereas some calculus would give them values for their components that would work the first time.

I've also seen people look up formulas in a book, and misapply them with no understanding. The formulas are understandable if you know calculus, but these people would get answers that didn't work and would just be befuddled.

Re:Peter Thiel Is Wrong About Higher Education (It’s Worse T... by smhinsey on Monday April 18, 2011 @07:00PM (#2461094)
I was one of those types who had a lot of problems with math in primary school because the style of "here are 150 problems for your homework tonight, just like every other night" didn't work with my learning style at all. It took me a long time to overcome this, and while I can't really give an example of this with calculus, I've run into this with other similarly "advanced" mathematical branches such as combinatorics, which comes up in all sorts of CS contexts dealing with trees or similar data structures.