News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Would it be possible to detect an industrial civilization... by TeMPOraL on Saturday September 26, 2020 @07:15PM (#24602887)
Interesting thought in your second paragraph. Through similar reasoning it would also follow that one of the bigger forces promoting science - or at least applied science - would be war. It's one of those things that keep you grounded in reality - the ship will either sail or it will sink; the shell will either land on target or it will miss. When your invention is going to be put into combat use, you can't get away with nice-sounding stories. You get instant and often visceral feedback.
Re:Would it be possible to detect an industrial civilization... by lopmotr on Saturday September 26, 2020 @07:49PM (#24603063)
I'd say so but only once the science is advanced enough to be of more use than technology developed by trail and error and intuition, which is a pretty high bar. Just think that when steam engines were already in use commercially, we didn't even have the law of conservation of energy, and the whole field of thermodynamics was developed afterwards. We made metal and gunpowder without chemistry, electric lights without electromagnetism, etc.

For clarity, I'm not counting engineering and technology as science. You can develop techniques for building ships that float without understanding anything about buoyancy or mechanics of materials but just though gradual evolution of ideas and passing knowledge down through generations of craftsmen.

Re:Would it be possible to detect an industrial civilization... by CryptoPunk on Saturday September 26, 2020 @07:44PM (#24603047)
More broadly: survival. The crop that will grow or wither, the patient who will recover or die. Etc.
Re:Would it be possible to detect an industrial civilization... by lopmotr on Saturday September 26, 2020 @08:12PM (#24603179)
That's quite a different concept. Agriculture techniques would have evolved that way but entirely devoid of science or understanding of how they worked, just evolution of ideas ossified into wisdom. Colonists in new countries experienced crop failures because they couldn't predict how things would behave in the different climates/ecosystems and just applied their "dumb" knowledge. I heard about a hunter-gatherer society that used a seemingly pointless ritual to decide where to get food each day. They had only a superstitious explanation of how it worked until we eventually figured out that the ritual was actually a random number generator that helped them to spread their gathering more uniformly or prevent prey from learning their habits or something along those lines. We can do a lot without understanding.

Medicine was a complete shit-show until modern science because people didn't even understand how to test if it caused patients to live or die! Even today in modern China, doctors still prescribe useless herbs based on superstition. They've stripped away the obvious nonsense about stars and planets that it used originally but still explain it using a mythical description of how the body works and how traditional medicines interact with it.

Re:Would it be possible to detect an industrial civilization... by CryptoPunk on Sunday September 27, 2020 @03:16AM (#24604866)
I guess you could say domains involving physical construction that had to be customized to varying circumstances required better understanding of the underlying physical processes at play.

So building war implements, like weapons and armor, and techniques, like how to target a canon, but also non-military disciplines, like the construction of buildings and bridges, the manufacture of commercial goods, etc.