But lets examine your "magical thinking" hypothesis.
Are some people more able to govern effectively as dictators? Is it possible that this governing ability can be effected both by a highly tailored up-bringing and genetics? If both these points are true then a hypothesis that says that an ability to rule effectively follows a particularly family/group of families who have ruled over generations and established a specific training regimen for offspring could find high validity.
As I've aged the idea of benevolent dictatorship has grown to be attractive. It seems all forms of [choosing] government are flawed and finding the least flawed is rather difficult.
Anyway, if you Want talented dictators there are a dozen obvious ways to find them, the very lamest (ineffective) of which is "choose from the same inbred line for centuries".