Not especially - 99.9% of people have doors that are adequate to keep burglars out, but the cops can kick them down or break a window if they need to, in an emergency.
Which is exactly what encryption backdoor advocates want.
Encryption is different. Making encryption that is nigh impossible to break is almost trivial these days. And the police has no recourse.
Whether that is an acceptable change from before is very much up for discussion, but we should be clear that something did change.
If the security forces don't have a master key for E2E encryption they should instead find another way to find evidence of a crime if they suspect one has taken place. The analogy does fall down somewhat when thinking about completely digital crimes when there is no physical evidence, one that comes to mind is child abuse, though this could be detected by teachers/care givers or analyzing videos/pictures from users which didn't practice good OPSEC.
I forget which group it was (Lizard Squad? LulzSec?) where one of the members was identified by analyzing internet usage and monitoring the suspects coming and going.
Change the analogy to a safe. No matter how good the safe, if police want, they can read the contents of the documents in my safe. The same can not be said for contents of encrypted documents.
Now, it might be possible for the police to persecute someone without access to those documents. Certainly, I am not arguing 'the police need this access because they used to have it'. All I am arguing is that encryption came with a meaningful change in what law enforcement can and cannot access without cooperation.
Claiming that we don't even need to consider the question because nothing meaningful changed is wrong. I don't believe we need to make that claim to argue against banning e2e encryption though.
> Locking the door of your house (with near impossible to break locks) prevents us to find out what you're doing/keeping in your house, so we can't know whether you're doing/keeping something illegal in your house. So we are going to ban the making and using of unbreakable (or infeasable to break open) locks for locking the door of your house.
< The law-enforcement people as well as the criminals will be able to break into my house. What about that?
Do you like this analogy?