News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Atlas Winced by Tycho on Sunday April 17, 2011 @02:53PM (#2456686)
We still do not know what information Rand had when she wrote what. The whole point is something made an impression on her and then she explored that emotional response to come up with ideas for a story. If you want to judge her on her emotional response, you at least need to be sure what she was responding to: for instance, I might have an emotional response to Saddam Hussein grandstanding in the crimes against humanity trial if I saw that on television, one quite different if the tv spot had simply featured images of his chemical attacks or torture victims.

"Even if that was all that fascinated her about Hickman (doubtful), it's quite interesting what conclusions she drew from his words: not that that kind of attitude could lead egomaniacs like Hickman to senseless murder but rather that they are ideals to be emulated and praised."

It's less interesting when you consider that other parts of her philosophy include a total rejection of violence.

"Are you kidding me? The section she wrote it in is titled "The Hickman Case", and it's clear she is talking about that case in particular from beginning to end. The entire section reinforces what she said in that quote. She said it and meant it about the Hickman case. There's no doubt about that."

Maybe you misunderstood what I wrote... but I strongly disagree. Here's the whole paragraph:

  The first thing that impresses me about the case
^ so she starts off addressing a specific event

  is the ferocious rage of the whole society against one man.
^ and then picks out a more general phenomenon present in this case

  No matter what the man did, there is always something loathsome in the "virtuous"

  indignation and mass-hatred of the "majority." One always feels the stuffy,

  bloodthirsty emotion of a mob in any great public feeling of a large 

  number of humans. It is repulsive to see all those beings with worse sins and 

  crimes in their own lives, virtuously condemning a criminal, proud

  and secure in their number, yelling furiously in defense of society.
^ And then describes the general phenomenon as she has observed from other instances. Then she goes back to talking about Hickman. Prescott omitted the middle sentence of the last section above to make it sound worse, which I think is very dishonest
Re:Atlas Winced by gnosis on Sunday April 17, 2011 @03:31PM (#2456787)
"It's less interesting when you consider that other parts of her philosophy include a total rejection of violence."

That's kind of ironic, if not outright hypocritical considering that outrage against violence is exactly what she's railing against in this journal entry.

She certainly didn't waste much time rejecting Hickman's violence there.

"And then describes the general phenomenon as she has observed from other instances."

First, it's not clear whether the last sentence you quote (the one you agree is dispicable were Rand referring to the Hickman case) is directly referring to the Hickman case or to the subject of the previous sentence, the "mob in any great public feeling". She doesn't mention the Hickman case by name in that sentence, nor does she explicitly mention she's talking about subject of the previous sentence.

But even were we to grant that she wasn't talking about the Hickman case directly, but was only talking about "a mob", she'd still be talking about the Hickman case indirectly; since it's obvious the mob she mentions is a general phenomena of which she saw the Hickman case as a particular example of.

So either way, she's talking about the Hickman case. Directly or indirectly.

In fact, the rest of the journal entry makes it crystal clear what Rand says in that sentence is indeed what she feels towards the spectators and prosecutors of the Hickman: "It is repulsive to see all those beings with worse sins and crimes in their own lives, virtuously condemning a criminal, proud and secure in their number, yelling furiously in defense of society."

Read the rest of the "Hickman Case" section from her journal and you'll see that very sentiment expressed by Rand towards the spectators and prosectors of the Hickman case. You can virtually see the scorn and contempt dripping from Rand's lips, not at some abstract and general example of "a mob", but precisely at those people who were outraged by what Hickman had done.

Re:Atlas Winced by Tycho on Sunday April 17, 2011 @04:15PM (#2456896)
She certainly didn't waste much time rejecting Hickman's violence there.

This is getting a bit silly, I mean, why would she? It's her private diary which she's using to plan works of fiction. She doesn't need to explain to herself that she doesn't condone violence.

Secondly, the contention is that Rand thought most people had 'worse sins' than child murder. One could conceivably interpret her sentence to mean that, but I think the only reason anyone has is because Michael Prescott ellipted the quotation in his article. It is vastly more likey that Rand was still speaking generally, and it reads that way more naturally.

Thirdly, she does indeed have many (other) negative things to say about the mob in this specific instance, but they are reasonable criticisms. For instance the enthusiasm of the newstand boys crying 'they're going to hang him!' It's when mass-approval crosses the line into unhealthy mass-relishment of a situation. And people coming out of the woodwork to associate themselves with the moral highground.

Basically she saw this case, saw the public reaction, and detected something in that reaction which wasn't motivated merely by the crime itself, but the criminal's open defiance of the social order. It inspired her to write a story about someone who also cared nothing for the social order, who wanted his own success above all alse, but was not a phoney or a hypocrit in any way, or a danger to others, and committed a crime for which he was widely hated: not because of the crime itself, but because he refused to acknowledge its wrongfulness. The initial story was never written but you can see the same pattern in The Fountainhead when Roark blows up the housing complex then goes on trial. Rand was not interested in Hickman, but in a parallel to the Hickman story that shared some of the same elements.

There were, of course, many, many other murders which Rand wasn't interested in whatsoever.

Re:Atlas Winced by gnosis on Sunday April 17, 2011 @04:47PM (#2456976)
"She doesn't need to explain to herself that she doesn't condone violence."

Then why did she explain to herself that she condemned the "mob" who was outraged by Hickman's murder?

"Secondly, the contention is that Rand thought most people had 'worse sins' than child murder. One could conceivably interpret her sentence to mean that, but I think the only reason anyone has is because Michael Prescott ellipted the quotation in his article. It is vastly more likey that Rand was still speaking generally, and it reads that way more naturally."

Even if we take her statement to apply more generally towards "a mob in any great public feeling of a large number of humans" is it really any more excusable? She'd presumably feel the same contempt not only towards those people who expressed outrage at Hickman's murder, but at similar outrage expressed against any murder.

"It's when mass-approval crosses the line into unhealthy mass-relishment of a situation. And people coming out of the woodwork to associate themselves with the moral highground."

And that "unhealthy mass-relishment" is more worthy of contempt and reproach than Hickman's own crime?

Re:Atlas Winced by Tycho on Sunday April 17, 2011 @05:35PM (#2457090)
Then why did she explain to herself that she condemned the "mob" who was outraged by Hickman's murder?

The outrage of the mob was what she was studying to write her fiction. She is detailing the characteristics and behaviours which she wants to portray - violence/murder was not going to be a part of her story, so she didn't write about it.

She'd presumably feel the same contempt not only towards those people who expressed outrage at Hickman's murder, but at similar outrage expressed against any murder.

She's not alluding to other murders, but to lesser 'crimes' that provoke a more hypocritical mass-response. Here the public response to Hickman wasn't hypocritical (except for his wife-murdering cellmate), but there were other things she didn't like about it. Let's note that most murders actually don't provoke a mass outrage - people are just quietly glad when the murderer is caught/sentenced. Mind you, Rand's early years probably weren't that far removed from the groutesque spectacle of public executions in front of actual mobs, which I suspect most people now find despicable.

And that "unhealthy mass-relishment" is more worthy of contempt and reproach than Hickman's own crime?

Again you are forgetting this is a private diary for planning fiction, not an newspaper editorial on a public affair. 'Worthy' has got nothing to do with it. Murders happen all the time. Many books are written about them already. It's not like this would be the first murder ever and that was Rand's response to it. This was a murder case with a difference, and Rand wanted to explore that difference. The question is not 'what is just and fair in this story,' but 'what is interesting in this story?'

Re:Atlas Winced by gnosis on Monday April 18, 2011 @03:35AM (#2458311)
"The outrage of the mob was what she was studying to write her fiction. She is detailing the characteristics and behaviours which she wants to portray - violence/murder was not going to be a part of her story, so she didn't write about it."

True. But you can see she had a strong emotional response to the circumstances of the Hickman case. She was really outraged, and ranted about her outrage for pages upon pages upon pages.

But her outrage was focused not on Hickman or on the murder he committed, but on those people who were outraged at what Hickman had done.

That's what's strange about her reaction. She doesn't seem to be concerned in the least by what Hickman had done. In fact, she idolizes him, and even writes a story in which she turns him in to a hero.

And it's not like there weren't plenty of cases of miscarriages of justice in the 20's that she could have been outraged at. Plenty of cases where she could have chosen to idolize and emulate someone who really was heroic.

Instead in her journal entry she writes of a child murderer being a hero. You don't find her choice of heroes to be even a bit strange?

"She's not alluding to other murders, but to lesser 'crimes' that provoke a more hypocritical mass-response."

What makes you think that? By her own words, she's referring to: "a mob in any great public feeling of a large number of humans" That includes public outrage at murders, mass murders, torture, etc.

The fact that she alluded to such mobs in relation to the Hickman case proves that she wasn't talking about mobs that form only in response to "lesser" crimes, but rather those of which the public outrage caused by the Hickman case is an example (ie. murder cases).

"Rand's early years probably weren't that far removed from the groutesque spectacle of public executions in front of actual mobs, which I suspect most people now find despicable."

If she had written about her outrage at the lynching of an innocent black man, I think most people today would agree with her and indeed find such an event despicable.

But Hickman was not lynched by a mob (he even got what appears to be a pretty fair trial, especially by the standards of the day), he was not innocent, and he wasn't a member of any persecuted minority. Furthermore, his crime was itself of a particularly despicable sort.

The only way Rand could have chosen a worse person to idolize was if she'd chosen a mass murderer or serial killer. In fact, Hickman wasn't really all that far from a serial killer, as there are some indications he'd killed before.

"It's not like this would be the first murder ever and that was Rand's response to it."

But it was a particularly gruesome murder of a child. You'd think that Rand herself would have been outraged by it. Instead she idolized the perpetrator and had nothing but contempt for those that would dare disparage him.

Re:Atlas Winced by Tycho on Monday April 18, 2011 @09:05AM (#2458910)
Why do you keep saying she 'idolized' him? She didn't, she idealized him, which is different. She's drawn to the case because she really liked his statement, 'I'm like the state, what's good for me is right.' From there she plans a story about a character based on his positive traits, but free from his negative ones, his 'degeneracy.'

She writes about the mob because the mob will be the antagonist in her story. She doesn't think the member of the mob in this case had 'worse sins' than murder in their own lives (I mean you could interpret it that way, but it's a stretch, plus is uncharacteristically stupid, plus is something Rand would have actually explained if that's what she meant - she's always crystal clear about explaining her beliefs), but nevertheless it's the same 'mob-mentality' at work as found elsewhere. A lynch mob is different, I'm talking about the crowds of people who turned up to see public executions, basically making justice a form of entertainment masquerading as moral superiority. The worst cases would be witch-trials or execution for 'treason', or counterfeiters, or show-trials in Russia. The modern instances would probably be the Enron or Royal Bank of Scotland inquiries, where although there was guilt, one has to say 'give me a fucking break' when all these former-colleagues or regulators line up to wash their hands and denounce the scapegoat. Then you have the 'celebrity speaks out of turn' stories, where people act like nothing they ever say in private is just as bad. All cases have different details, but the argument is that the mob-mentality is somewhat consistent throughout.

Once again this is a private diary for planning fiction. It's not 'Ayn Rand's Memoirs, Chapter 6: What I thought of William Hickman.' Or 'Ayn Rand: My Heroes.' Rand is in the process of forumulating a philosophy that eschews collectivism and along comes a prominent news story where she gets a chance to study the mob-mentality in reaction to someone who is not a collectivist whatsoever. Murders are very common, but ones which become huge public spectacles are not. It is not sufficient to ask 'why is the public so outraged?' The question becomes 'why is the public so outraged about this instance, but not others?'