News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IPhone: The New Personal Computer by aneesh on Monday July 14, 2008 @08:00AM (#245642)
> "but with the platform iPhone becomes the new personal computer .... Every major service, Amazon, Netflx, Twitter, Digg, Flickr, Facebook, is already available, or will soon be, ... this is powerful and unprecedented

Unprecedented? Surely not. Windows Mobile is a platform that allows you to do all that. Blackberry is another mobile platform for developers. iPhone may yet be the best mobile platform (the jury's still out), but it's certainly not the first.

Re:IPhone: The New Personal Computer by wallflower on Monday July 14, 2008 @10:45AM (#245737)
Apple's reality distortion field is in full-effect - I think of not being too far from religious fundamentalism (in terms of how people love to preach about the product). It's impossible to separate hyperbole from Apple - it's fundamental to their ethos.

The Razr was one of the best-selling phones of all-time. We have to give it props. However, how many people would stand in line for the new Razr (for four hours)? The Samsung Instinct? Or even for the still-in-development (touch-screen) Blackberry Thunder?

I own (and am very happy and even happier with the 2.0 firmware) the 1st generation iPhone (since I upgraded from an ancient Nokia 8265 it was going from the horse-and-buggy to a limo).

Re:IPhone: The New Personal Computer by bigbang on Monday July 14, 2008 @08:32AM (#245654)
Right. But, with the ability of 3 party developers to develop applications for the iphone(and make some money) creates lot of interesting applications unlike Blackberry or windows mobile.
Re:IPhone: The New Personal Computer by aneesh on Monday July 14, 2008 @08:47AM (#245665)
The Windows Mobile is over a decade old as a platform for apps. The Blackberry also allows 3rd party apps.

As a platform, there's nothing new here with the iPhone except lots of hype and a slick UI.

Re:IPhone: The New Personal Computer by riahi on Monday July 14, 2008 @01:43PM (#245871)
The comparison between the iPhone UI and Windows Mobile UI is the crux of the matter. With a device that you use dozens of times a day, every single day, the UI better be damn good. As of now, the UI on mobile devices has not been good. I've had a Dell Axim x51v running Windows Mobile 5 and 6, and let me tell you, this pda would crash at least once a day due to memory leaks or other gibberish. I shudder to think what the phone versions of Windows Mobile are like, since just the PDA was so unstable.

This also reminds me of the people trying to rid Verizon phones from their horrific UI and replace it with the UI that originally comes on the phones. Just because VZW-UI and Motorola-UI phones are equally functional, does not mean the UI does not matter.

Re:IPhone: The New Personal Computer by mrtron on Monday July 14, 2008 @09:48AM (#245695)
I suppose that selling your app through iTunes is the first example of one of these providers creating a distribution and sales network for your 3rd party apps though.

But winmobile and blackberry platforms have been in existence for years and years.

Re:IPhone: The New Personal Computer by Tichy on Monday July 14, 2008 @10:09AM (#245704)
There are lots and lots of platforms for buying mobile applications. Not sure if there is one explicitly BY Blackberry, but still.
Re:IPhone: The New Personal Computer by yawn on Monday July 14, 2008 @12:04PM (#245811)
The problem is mindshare. No one knows what they are. I remember a site called "handango" (I just checked and they are still there) that handled this, but most people have no idea of where to go for their content. Apple's answer is iTunes: a familiar interface for anyone that owns an iPod.
Re:IPhone: The New Personal Computer by Tichy on Monday July 14, 2008 @02:49PM (#245932)
In Germany everybody knows Jamba, but everybody hates them.

Also, every network operator has tried to create their own platform (O2, T-Mobile, e-plus, Vodafone) - not so different from Apple after all? But nobody trusts the network operators (rightfully so), and awareness for mobile applications was not very big. I guess iPhone has an advantage because apps are a key marketing ingredient.

Re:IPhone: The New Personal Computer by DanielBMarkham on Monday July 14, 2008 @08:38AM (#245661)
Er -- Windows Mobile is an open platform. Developers have been developing apps on it for many years now.
Re:IPhone: The New Personal Computer by jimbokun on Monday July 14, 2008 @12:20PM (#245822)
Can't remember the name of the author or the book, but he addressed the issue of the Vikings "discovering" the Americas before Columbus.

Well yes, in the sense that they were physically there earlier. But the author pointed out that rarely has a "discovery" had so little impact. For better or worse, Columbus' "discovery" led to mapping, further exploring, trading, colonization, etc. etc. (pillaging, plundering, exploiting, if you prefer). Which is why it is the one that gets mentioned in more history books.

If I'm being too subtle, Windows Mobile is the Vikings and iPhone Columbus in the above analogy.

Re:IPhone: The New Personal Computer by axod on Monday July 14, 2008 @10:57AM (#245747)
But who in their right mind would want windows anywhere near their phone? It's not fun writing for something like that.
Re:IPhone: The New Personal Computer by bbgm on Monday July 14, 2008 @02:53PM (#245938)
I use winmobile and have regretted it pretty much ever since. The interface is just not intuitive as a phone interface. Not that most phone interfaces are, but winmobile 5 at least is about as bad as it gets.
Re:IPhone: The New Personal Computer by dualogy on Monday July 14, 2008 @02:03PM (#245889)
Switched a very short while ago from the Windows to the Unix eco system but I can't confirm that it's the platform itself that makes or breaks the fun in developing.
Re:IPhone: The New Personal Computer by cstejerean on Monday July 14, 2008 @02:37PM (#245920)
I had a windows phone and I had to reboot it half a dozen times per day. It reminded me of my parent's windows machine (yes, I'll get around to buying them a Mac soon enough). IMHO having a stable platform with solid tools can make development fun.