News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The US Air Force has built and flown a prototype of its f... by aneutron on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @03:28AM (#24564056)
I do agree with the first idea. The second one is not always the best line of thought, especially when it's about sovereignty or defense.

Suppose you buy fighter jets from China, but tensions rise and you somehow cut diplomatic ties. How are you going to get maintenance parts. Very inaccurate example but just to illustrate that yes, economically, your idea makes sense. Geopolitically, it depends.

Re:The US Air Force has built and flown a prototype of its f... by lightgreen on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @03:35AM (#24564111)
> How are you going to get maintenance parts.

Buy the planes with spare parts and training. When calculating a price for a plane, include not just the price tag, but also the risks of getting these planes unusable in ten years.

So yes, buying jets from China might be not the best idea even if they initially seem cheaper. But that’s not the case for US jets.

Re:The US Air Force has built and flown a prototype of its f... by 10000truths on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @06:04AM (#24565119)
Spare parts and training are not enough to maintain a fleet of fighter jets. You need experienced in-house technicians to provide the maintenance and replace the black-box electronics, which means you're still at the mercy of whatever country manufactures the jets. Doesn't matter if it's China or the US, if they decide a year down the line that they don't like you, guess what? No servicing for you, and your fleet of fancy jets will only last until they break down, or get remotely disabled/bricked/self-destructed with a kill switch.

Maintaining a Sovereign Nation 101 is that you do not entrust your national security to another country. Sure, it's more expensive to do your own R&D and manufacturing, but you get the peace of mind that your continued existence does not depend on a foreign government's continual blessing.

Re:The US Air Force has built and flown a prototype of its f... by lightgreen on Thursday September 24, 2020 @10:26AM (#24578888)
Doesn't Sovereign Nation 101 teach, that if you spend too much GDP on military, soon you are in debt and then failed state, and no longer sovereign?
Re:The US Air Force has built and flown a prototype of its f... by wongarsu on Wednesday September 23, 2020 @04:45AM (#24564591)
> But that’s not the case for US jets.

Why? It's hard to predict how relationships with the US will look over the next 40 years (F-18 is 37 years old). Especially with relationships on a downward trajectory during Bush's and Trump's presidency.

Sure, the risk is a lot smaller than with China, but it does exist