Re:Really Atari ST?
by cmrdporcupine on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @08:05PM
(#24561492)
The reason they had to be formatted on a PC to be used by both was only due to endian-ness issues:
TOS was tolerant of both big and little endian FAT
While MSDOS tolerated only little-endian.
However the GEM desktop's formatting utility formatted big-endian only.
So to get a floppy readable on both you formatted under MSDOS. Or used a better formatting utility on your Atari that let you choose little endian mode.
That's triply dumb, because of the typo noted in the article, and also because executable Atari ST bootsectors had a checksum that should be computed instead of silly heuristics, but most importantly because most Atari ST disks had no executable bootsector, but the entries concerning disk layout were still valid.
It sounds exactly like the fractal of incompetence Microsoft would implement, and it would explain why we Atarians had to use disks formatted on a PC for data transfer, even though the formats were nominally the same. Funny to read about that, because back in the day, I thought the ST somehow formatted disks "wrong".