News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DOS Subsystem for Linux by hyperpape on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @02:43PM (#24558277)
This is helpful, but the composition rules are weird and confusing.

It's true that a Linux Subsystem is a subsystem of Linux, but an "X for Linux" is a component of Linux or an application for Linux.

When you put them together, it seems that the "for" wins the battle. In parsing terminology, it has lower precedence (though I'm sure the actual rules of English are more complex than that indicates).

I'd love to see an actual linguist comment on why this phrase is so confusing.

Re:DOS Subsystem for Linux by evilsnoopi3 on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @03:02PM (#24558479)
I have an English degree and can confidently say the issue is the implicit understood possessive in the correct parsing. As it stands, “for” dominates mentally because the phrase obviously needs a possessive to make sense and “for” denotes possession. If it were “Window’s Subsystem for Linux” or “DOS’s Subsystem for Linux”, explicating the proper possession, the parsing trouble would disappear.
Re:DOS Subsystem for Linux by waheoo on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @09:05PM (#24561878)
So would just saying Linux subsystem for windows.

Which was raised when this name came up but they didn't like that Linux came first so went with gymnastic language instead.

Its even more obvious with this new name.

Its a Linux subsystem for DOS.