Re:Old TV caused village broadband outages for 18 months
by tialaramex on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @01:57PM
(#24557725)
The returns are indeed diminishing. But in a multi-person household I can totally buy that 20Mbps just doesn't feel like enough. If one of you is doing a big download and then two more try to watch Netflix, that's going to suck. Some of this is made worse because of Buffer Bloat (which you should cure), but ultimately 20Mbps won't stretch very far in a typical 3-4 person household, and some British homes have half a dozen or more Internet users (a newborn isn't using the Internet, but both a toddler watching a cartoon and grandma catching up with old friends on Zoom are).
Also in practice the same services (even if with different branding) are offered to small businesses. If you can't afford to lease serious offer space that might come with dedicated fibre you'll be buying whatever the fastest broadband available to consumers is, and maybe paying extra for it. So if the best available was 20Mbps that's going to suck for an office of twenty people.
So I'm comfortable with plans that say (a) it makes sense to deploy fibre where you're going from scratch and (b) it makes sense to offer 1Gbps where practical even if most of your price sensitive customers are happy at more like 50Mbps. My scepticism is reserved for people who insist that (a) anything less than fibre to every home is a betrayal and (b) everybody "needs" gigabit or better because this will enable some mythical yet-to-be invented new service that justifies the excess.
Also in practice the same services (even if with different branding) are offered to small businesses. If you can't afford to lease serious offer space that might come with dedicated fibre you'll be buying whatever the fastest broadband available to consumers is, and maybe paying extra for it. So if the best available was 20Mbps that's going to suck for an office of twenty people.
So I'm comfortable with plans that say (a) it makes sense to deploy fibre where you're going from scratch and (b) it makes sense to offer 1Gbps where practical even if most of your price sensitive customers are happy at more like 50Mbps. My scepticism is reserved for people who insist that (a) anything less than fibre to every home is a betrayal and (b) everybody "needs" gigabit or better because this will enable some mythical yet-to-be invented new service that justifies the excess.