News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to Make Biomass Energy Sustainable Again by danans on Monday September 21, 2020 @03:04PM (#24547129)
If what they are talking about is the whole world returning to some kind of agrarian existence in order to make manually harvested biomass a sustainable energy source, that's not going to happen without a major civilizational collapse.

Then again, perhaps that's what the author is actually advocating . If so, it's not so surprising. There are a lot of cheerleaders for civilizational and especially institutional destruction these days, often just as a means to replace them with some other system more appealing to their personal preferences, whatever those are.

Renewables like wind and solar are hardly radical solutions for energy production anymore, despite the narratives coming out of fossil-fuel aligned political groups. They are just the obvious incremental next step in the evolution of harnessing solar energy. Yes, they are complicated enough technologies that, unlike biomass, they can't realistically be harnessed today without a dependency on global supply chains. If you consider that a problem, then well, that's a different topic altogether.

Re:How to Make Biomass Energy Sustainable Again by skyfaller on Monday September 21, 2020 @05:03PM (#24548449)
What Low-Tech Magazine is talking about is not mysterious or sinister. They advocate for reducing energy use, especially in developed nations, in order to reduce the difficulty of transitioning to renewable energy on a short enough timescale to avoid climate catastrophe. https://www.lowtechmagazine.com/2018/01/how-much-energy-do-w...
Re:How to Make Biomass Energy Sustainable Again by danans on Monday September 21, 2020 @07:36PM (#24549521)
The issue with Low-Tech-Magazine is the ludicrous way they advocate to lower energy use, by abandoning higher efficiency technology altogether, i.e:

"There are several ways to escape from the parallel universe of energy efficiency. First, while energy efficiency hinders significant long term reduction in energy demand through the need for equivalence of service, the opposite also holds true – making everything less energy efficient would reverse the growth in energy services and reduce energy demand"

"Likewise, if an “energy inefficiency policy” were to mandate the use of inefficient central heating boilers, heating large homes to present-day comfort standards would be unaffordable for most people. They would be forced to find alternative solutions to achieve thermal comfort, for instance heating only one room, dressing more warmly, using personal heating devices, or moving to a smaller home."

https://www.lowtechmagazine.com/2018/01/bedazzled-by-energy-...

It almost reads like marketing copy from the oil industry.

A far more sensible way to handle this is not to return to 1960s ICEs for cars and oil powered central heating boilers for heating (with all their associated local pollution damage), but rather to price renewable electricity appropriately to ensure efficient consumption by having rapidly increasing price tiers for higher usage consumers and time-of-use pricing based on supply and demand. This already happens in many places. This should also satisfy the requirements of those who wish impose a type of "noble hardship" upon the population, as it still subjects them (via pricing correlated with weather events) to the vagaries of nature, including weather (want to set your AC to 65 at 4PM during a heat wave, without a medical requirement? No problem, that will be $0.80/kWh).

Also, remember that the cost of producing renewable electricity is not based on the the marginal cost of generating it, but on the capital cost of building and financing it. That cost will drop, but it isn't going to zero any time soon. What is needed is for renewable+storage to drop in cost below the that of fossil fuels. We're almost there.

Re:How to Make Biomass Energy Sustainable Again by pmiller2 on Monday September 21, 2020 @11:22PM (#24550527)
This whole “reduce energy efficiency to reduce demand” business sounds like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox in reverse.
Re:How to Make Biomass Energy Sustainable Again by skyfaller on Monday September 21, 2020 @07:57PM (#24549626)
Yeah, I'll admit that this proposal to decrease energy efficiency in our technology is insanity. One major problem with it is that under capitalism polluters don't pay the true cost of the damage they do and very dangerous technology can be quite affordable. While I understand this proposal as merely listing an option and taking the argument to its logical conclusion, I can see why it could make you not take the rest of the article or website seriously.

I found the rest of the article and website very thoughtful and detailed with extensive sources, so I forgive the handful of batty positions taken because I find everything else to be useful data, historical research, and exercises in lateral thinking. It's clear to me that most people do not take the climate crisis seriously enough and seem to believe that we can continue acting exactly as we always have, while mere technological innovation will solve it. Low-Tech Mag generally advances solutions that are/were designed for a world where energy is expensive, and I find that quite compelling because that is the world we now live in, whether people realize it or not.

Re:How to Make Biomass Energy Sustainable Again by est31 on Monday September 21, 2020 @03:39PM (#24547550)
Small scale subsistence farming is still widespread around the globe in poorer countries. If they can, farmers try to send their children to schools so that they can have a better life. And many do! The reason why China can offer such cheap labour is because of this effect. Your laptop/smartphone etc was likely assembled by someone who's parent was a farmer. To say that subsistence farming is the only good lifestyle is western decadence tbh.
Re:How to Make Biomass Energy Sustainable Again by danans on Monday September 21, 2020 @04:03PM (#24547799)
6 or so generations back nearly all of our ancestors we're engaged in some sort of agrarian existence. There's plenty to be said for re-establishing the common knowledge people had back then with regards to growing their food - via things like allotment gardens, reintroducing the basics of farming in the educational system, etc - but the frequent fantasizing you see about returning industrial society broadly to an agrarian condition is often dishonest in its stated intent.

Very few want to return to agrarian society, but some want to use a reversion as a pretext for controlling industrial society toward illiberal ends.

Re:How to Make Biomass Energy Sustainable Again by 6nf on Monday September 21, 2020 @04:26PM (#24548057)
6 generations ago the earth had 1 billion people, we're closer to 8 billion now. What happened? Haber Bosch.

We can't go back without a massive reduction in population.

Re:How to Make Biomass Energy Sustainable Again by danans on Monday September 21, 2020 @04:37PM (#24548175)
That's the thing, I don't think that advocates for "going back" actually want to go back. It's a convenient ruse for seizing power, one that's easy to sell because it appeals to people's idealized views of the past.
Re:How to Make Biomass Energy Sustainable Again by TeMPOraL on Monday September 21, 2020 @05:40PM (#24548784)
Or they do want to go back. I know some people like that personally; they just don't comprehend what it would take to go back.

And it would take a huge population reduction (either up front, of through starvation after the shift to agrarian lifestyle). It would quite likely take rolling back the industrial revolution altogether - because it would be next to impossible for a reduced population of farmers to sustain current level of technology; all tools and things supported by it, including industrial chemistry and material science, would just degrade over coming decades and it couldn't be recreated. All of that is hard to imagine for someone with shallow understanding of how the world and technology behind it works.

Re:How to Make Biomass Energy Sustainable Again by fogihujy on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @01:14AM (#24551086)
I do. I have no illusion about it ever happening though.
Re:How to Make Biomass Energy Sustainable Again by est31 on Monday September 21, 2020 @04:41PM (#24548211)
Yeah absolutely, study past ways of living just how you'd study classical latin authors or other historical things. And if you like it, do subsistence farming yourself. But people have reasons why they drop it in masses. Don't think you are smarter than them just because you live in the west, or because you are particularly convinced of your ideology.
Re:How to Make Biomass Energy Sustainable Again by User23 on Monday September 21, 2020 @05:55PM (#24548888)
Small scale semi-subsistence farming is still widespread in the rural United States. It doesn't take much land to grow enough vegetables to feed a family for a year and chickens aren't too much of a hassle either. Even cows aren't too bad if you can get a timeslot with a butcher, but these days you can't.