News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to Make Biomass Energy Sustainable Again by philipkglass on Monday September 21, 2020 @02:11PM (#24546575)
The article has some interesting history but it also misleads by omission. Europe's forests were denuded by hand-tool harvesting of wood well before power tools were invented. The earliest use of coal in European iron making was motivated by charcoal supplies running short due to extensive deforestation.

When the article says "two-thirds of the wood that is harvested in developing societies is harvested sustainably" it's also saying "one third of the wood that is harvested in developing societies is harvested unsustainably." Even the very low energy consumption per capita of biomass-reliant populations is not sustainable at modern population densities.

Biomass is a very low efficiency method of converting sunlight to energy useful to humans. That's why mainstream scientific and environmental organizations are more interested in solar photovoltaic technology; PV can provide 50 times more useful energy per hectare than biomass. The "high tech" approach is not just fashion-driven technology for technology's sake.

https://wiki.opensourceecology.org/wiki/Comparison_of_Biomas...

https://www.biofuelwatch.org.uk/2018/biomass-and-land-use/

https://ucanr.edu/sites/WoodyBiomass/files/78993.pdf

Re:How to Make Biomass Energy Sustainable Again by hinkley on Monday September 21, 2020 @02:49PM (#24546981)
You have to factor in the embodied energy into the equation of power per hectare, including replacement and maintenance, and once you’ve done that, ask if the other services provided by agroforestry are ever worth more than the energy from the PV farm that can only be used during the day (or stored, in which case include the embodied and maintenance energy of the storage system, too).

We need to stop looking for One Weird Fix. It’s not out there, and /or we keep breaking it by changing the conditions. You will be looking for hedges, and some of those hedges will have stacking functions.

Re:How to Make Biomass Energy Sustainable Again by philipkglass on Monday September 21, 2020 @03:15PM (#24547246)
We need to stop looking for One Weird Fix. It’s not out there, and/or we keep breaking it by changing the conditions.

I'd agree with that. Low Tech Magazine keeps promoting One Weird Fix of "use less complicated technology." In early issues it highlighted a few simple old technologies that were plausibly equal or superior to modern complicated technologies. But it rapidly exhausted plausible candidates.

Recent Low Tech Magazine articles are good branching off points for exploring historical technologies but poor at conceiving solutions to the energy and environmental problems we face in the 21st century. They keep highlighting ideas that barely touch on today's largest energy demands or that require far too much land per person. I have a bunch of energy crisis books from the 1970s and they also frequently dreamt of a more rural existence than is now possible for Earth's billions of people. They kept invoking past lifestyles, ignoring how many fewer people there were in the past. The mismatch is even more severe in 2020 than it was in 1974.

Re:How to Make Biomass Energy Sustainable Again by hinkley on Monday September 21, 2020 @05:47PM (#24548830)
It's a complex problem. They're all complex problems when you have to solve them for 8 billion instead of 80,000

The more we automate the creation of food, water, clothing, and shelter, the fewer people we need to keep the rest of us from starving or freezing to death. What do the rest of us do for a living? Why do we keep going?

A very careful dose of pastoralism can address part of that problem. Locally produced goods also tend to have a smaller carbon footprint, so there's something there as well. There are people who think we can fix all of our problems that way, and so far I've carefully avoided having to tell any of them they're wrong.

Related to pastoralism is a bigger category: Stewardship. We could keep a lot of people in meaningful work by doing all of the deferred maintenance we're neglecting as we industrialize. Every time we find a new way to Go Fast and Break Things, we should be fixing what we break. Looking at sustainability and lifecycle costs.

There's a PR problem with becoming a glorified gardener. It's a janitor with a better class of filth but a higher risk of injury. The hype you see is, fundamentally, trying to raise the 'station' of a whole raft of professions and hobbies. Romanticizing them.

Re:How to Make Biomass Energy Sustainable Again by fogihujy on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @01:09AM (#24551057)
> The more we automate the creation of food, water, clothing, and shelter, the fewer people we need to keep the rest of us from starving or freezing to death. What do the rest of us do for a living? Why do we keep going?

Why would the few remaining workers elect to work only to provide for others?

Re:How to Make Biomass Energy Sustainable Again by hinkley on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @01:45AM (#24551267)
Right, so the first order problem is, “my self worth is in doubt.” And the second order problem is, “why am I busting my hump for these worthless do-nothings?”

Even if you manage not to sink into an existential pit of despair, some rabble rouser may incite the means of production to rebel against you, introducing an external existential threat. So the dignity you’re looking for may save your life, twice.

How do we do that, outside of intentional work slowdowns or Futurama suicide booths? Ever escalating consumption is the answer since WWII, but we are killing ourselves doing that. What else is there? You can start by doing all the things we never find the time to do. I don’t know how we solve that problem for the great grandkids, though. Probably involves space colonies. Mars would be a ridiculously massive jobs creation program.

Re:How to Make Biomass Energy Sustainable Again by vagrantJin on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @10:05AM (#24554480)
Mars would create meaning in peoples work. Not just work for its own sake. The long shitty hours and crappy conditions could be justified as a man who is building his family's house with his own hands.
Re:How to Make Biomass Energy Sustainable Again by dragonwriter on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @10:10AM (#24554527)
Sure, a frontier is an (extremely temporary, usually) relief from the alienation of capitalism for those on it.

OTOH, if the alienation of capitalism is really the problems you want to address, Mars is an extremely expensive way to solve it, even temporarily, for a very small slice of the people who are afflicted by it.

Re:How to Make Biomass Energy Sustainable Again by fogihujy on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @02:53AM (#24551676)
Definitely. Selling dreams about a better life and tickets to some colony has proved to be a reliable way of handling it. Time will tell.
Re:How to Make Biomass Energy Sustainable Again by Scoundreller on Monday September 21, 2020 @03:57PM (#24547744)
> Biomass is a very low efficiency method of converting sunlight to energy useful to humans.

Has great storage efficiency though.