News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Education Inflation, Technological Advancement, and Cogni... by Retric on Saturday April 16, 2011 @02:01PM (#2454451)
The problem with a fixed cost is for plenty of poeple an extra 10k/year is meaningless but for others it's a huge deal. A possibly better approach would be a 1% increase in your income tax (for life) if you get a Masters/MBA/etc. The net effect is similar (3 mil lifetime earnings = 30k in extra tax). But it scales with income so it attacks the value of signaling.
Re:Education Inflation, Technological Advancement, and Cogni... by yummyfajitas on Saturday April 16, 2011 @02:14PM (#2454491)
The harm to society is also fixed, so charging a % of profits is a strange way to tax. Think of degree inflation as being a form of pollution.

Now think directly about pollution taxes. Emitting 1kg of pollution to create an iPod is not a bad thing - iPods are more valuable than having 1kg less pollution in the air. Emitting 1kg of pollution to make a sandwich is bad, however, since the value of a sandwich is much lower than 1kg less pollution. The end goal is to pollute only while making iPods, not sandwiches.

Charging as a % of profits or revenues would not create this incentive.

Similarly, the goal of an education tax is to create a disincentive for acquiring a degree for people who won't gain a lot from the degree.

Re:Education Inflation, Technological Advancement, and Cogni... by Retric on Saturday April 16, 2011 @03:42PM (#2454673)
"The harm to society is also fixed". No it scales with the amount of productivity lost during that time period. A football player that get's a masters before going to the NFL has a greater cost and a lower benefit than a teacher that get's a masters before teaching high-school English.
Re:Education Inflation, Technological Advancement, and Cogni... by Alex3917 on Saturday April 16, 2011 @02:20PM (#2454507)
"The end goal is to pollute only while making iPods, not sandwiches."

Actually, the end goal would be to reduce the total amount of pollution.

Re:Education Inflation, Technological Advancement, and Cogni... by yummyfajitas on Saturday April 16, 2011 @02:34PM (#2454528)
Why?

Pollution has a cost and production has a benefit. If $BENEFIT - $COST > 0, we want more pollution.

The problem is that since pollution is an external cost, the producer/consumer has no incentive to accurately make this calculation. As long as $BENEFIT > 0, the producer/consumer will pollute, and society will pay $COST.

The point of the Pigouvian tax is to give the producer/consumer an incentive to make this calculation correctly, and to compensate the rest of society for the costs they impose.