The US government would also run into opposition from groups like the EFF, and I think it would be difficult to word the law to ban bitcoins specifically, and not other similar mathematical activities (like issuing SSL certificates).
I thought legislation had been passed stating that purveyors of pre-paid debit cards and cell phones had to ask for ID and keep records so that, if the cards or phones were used in a crime, the purchaser could be traced. I do know that legislation to that effect was introduced. I'm not sure if it was ratified, but even if anonymous cards and phones are legal now, I have no confidence that they will continue to be legal for the foreseeable future.
There is a tendency to be pessimistic about the place of anonymity in the future, but I prefer to look on the bright side. The US government doesn't win every fight it enters, and there is a long-term trend toward more freedom and openness, rather than the opposite way around.
Who wouldn't care? At 3 days, you might as well just mail around cash.
That said, I don't think this is the most interesting part of bitcoins.