News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: How to structure an LLC for giving out equity by jasonkolb on Saturday April 16, 2011 @11:41AM (#2454134)
LLC's are ripoffs. Use an S-Corp instead. They are far cheaper and easier, are FAR more flexible, and you get the same tax benefits.

LLC's are for people who don't know any better (and this includes myself, several times now in the past, having only been fully educated in this area fairly recently).

Re:Ask HN: How to structure an LLC for giving out equity by jeffepp on Saturday April 16, 2011 @12:28PM (#2454241)
In Michigan you can form a LLC for $50. It's super simple.

EDIT: I am also an attorney, but have never practiced. In most cases a LLC is the best way to incorporate your startup. (Unless, you know you are getting funding ASAP)

Re:Ask HN: How to structure an LLC for giving out equity by jasonkolb on Saturday April 16, 2011 @12:42PM (#2454271)
Ok, how much is the yearly filing fee? How are profits taxed? How do you distribute ownership interest?

Super simple to set up, complex as hell to use.

Re:Ask HN: How to structure an LLC for giving out equity by Terretta on Saturday April 16, 2011 @12:03PM (#2454193)
This comment is almost exactly backwards for most startup purposes.

In particular, S Corp compliance is more tedious and costly, while ownership structure is less flexible.

Re:Ask HN: How to structure an LLC for giving out equity by jasonkolb on Saturday April 16, 2011 @12:38PM (#2454261)
Ok, let me respond a little more since I'm not on my iPad trying to peck out a response. Will try to get all of the questions answered in one shot here.

Why is it a ripoff? In my state (IL) it costs $250 annually to keep your LLC in good standing, while it costs $75 a year for an S-Corp.

Why is it a ripoff, reason number 2? When you form an LLC you have to spend lots of time with your lawyer hashing out things like what happens to the company when you die, if you have a partner the complexity of the operating agreement goes up exponentially. With a corp all of these things are already determined for you by a huge body of corporate law. With an LLC you are reinventing the wheel. Based on the original question this is a no-brainer for the poster, this alone is a big enough reason to scrap the LLC idea immediately.

Why is it a ripoff, reason number 3? The reason your tax guy is telling you it's a good deal is because of the pass through loss/profit which falls through to you. If you dig deep enough you will discover that an LLC really IS you for most purposes, especially if you own 100% of the shares. It is not a separate legal entity unless you have more than one shareholder (go look it up).

As far as complexity, that's bullshit. I would venture that 100% of the people who say this nonsense have no idea what you actually need to do in order to keep a corp in good standing. Yes, you need to have minutes of your annual meeting, even if it's something as simple as "the annual meeting was held over lunch and nothing of note was discussed". It is not rocket science, it's just scary when you're not familiar with it.

Now for the really big reason: if you make a profit with an LLC, you will pay self-employment tax. If you take profits with an S-corp it is dividend income (or share buybacks, etc). You WILL pay more taxes using an LLC than an S-corp simply because you have far less flexibility owing to the fact that the corp is a separate legal entity while that is an extreme grey area for an LLC. I strongly suspect this is why people are generally herded towards LLC's, simply because they are easier to track and tax than corps.

Your average CPA is useless when talking about these topics, they are used to talking about real estate tax deductions and dependents, not the intricacies of setting up a legal entity with the flexibility to deal with other legal entities, distribute shares, etc.

Re:Ask HN: How to structure an LLC for giving out equity by gte910h on Saturday April 16, 2011 @12:57PM (#2454297)
Let's go into a few points:

Costs. My state has the opposite (corps more expensive than LLCs), So this is a YMMV thing.

>Why is it a ripoff, reason number 2? When you form an LLC you have to spend lots of time with your lawyer hashing out things like what happens to the company when you die

It is almost trivial to change the LLC operating agreement. Sure, once you start to get into it, you can get more complex, but this again, is something you can do easily again later once you're sure you are sticking with this thing.

>Why is it a ripoff, reason number 3? The reason your tax guy is telling you it's a good deal is because of the pass through loss/profit which falls through to you

Only for 1 of the three ways to do LLCs. You can do LLCs as a disregarded entity (what you're talking about, which is simple as hell, but has a generally higher tax burden). You can elect to treat your LLC as a C-Corp for federal tax purposes (and state). This, for tax purposes, is basically a C corp, with all that matters under the tax law. You can elect to treat your LLC as a S-Corp (what I do). This allows you to do damn near everything you can as an actual S-Corp with oodles more flexibility, generally smaller filing fees, and a much faster setup with no annual meeting, etc, requirements.

>Now for the really big reason: if you make a profit with an LLC, you will pay self-employment tax. If you take profits with an S-corp it is dividend income (or share buybacks, etc).

Only if it's a disregarded entity. You do not pay self employment tax with a LLC taking a S-Corp election, you pay active owners a salary(on which you pay SS and medicare) and any other income is reported on schedule K (which does not trigger self employment tax; self employment tax is a stand in for SS and Medicare taxes).

> You WILL pay more taxes using an LLC than an S-corp simply because you have far less flexibility owing to the fact that the corp is a separate legal entity while that is an extreme grey area for an LLC.

No it's not. LLCs are better statutorily defined than corporations actually. They are quite clearly defined. Generally speaking, disregarded entities (what you apparently had) are considerably closer to a sole proprietorship than S-Corp and C-Corp elected LLCs. This is why I say "You should probably be doing a S or C corp LLC".

>Your average CPA is useless when talking about these topics,

You need to find a small business CPA. They know tons about this. If you go to an estate planning expert, don't expect tons of tricks in the small business department. CPAs have specialties just like coders do. You wouldn't have your ruby guru write your C microcontroller code. Same deal with accountants. I've been to two small business CPAs who both sung "S-Corp election of a LCC" from the top of the highest mountains.

Re:Ask HN: How to structure an LLC for giving out equity by Terretta on Saturday April 16, 2011 @03:18PM (#2454623)
> In my state (IL) it costs $250 annually to keep your LLC in good standing, while it costs $75 a year for an S-Corp.

The other reply to yours is detailed and refutes each of your points, so I'll just address this. If you're thinking this $175 difference is relevant, you should probably just stick with a sole proprietorship.

On seven figures of revenue, my main LLC's tax bill (company + members, the same CPA handling it all) is some $7500 a year, but would run twice that as an S corp, and about four times that as a C corp.

Before this company, the last LLC I was a member of grew to 8 figures a year in revenue as an LLC, and changed to C corp only when we took $27M in funding. Prior to those, and before receiving genuinely good advice on the flexibility afforded by LLCs when pursuing high growth and investment, I used S corps. By comparison, LLCs are fantastic.

PS. "Go look it up" seems a little snide.

Re:Ask HN: How to structure an LLC for giving out equity by georgecmu on Saturday April 16, 2011 @11:53AM (#2454167)
Can you elaborate on how an LLC is a rip-off? (It may also be useful to mention your state). So far, in Pennsylvania, I've had a different experience.
Re:Ask HN: How to structure an LLC for giving out equity by jasonkolb on Saturday April 16, 2011 @12:43PM (#2454275)
It depends on what you are doing. If you are losing money and not trying to transfer ownership interests you will have no problem. Once you start making money or want to do anything a tiny bit more complex you have created a hornet's nest for yourself.
Re:Ask HN: How to structure an LLC for giving out equity by Terretta on Saturday April 16, 2011 @03:22PM (#2454632)
Again, my last LLC earned 8 figures a year in revenue with several accredited investor bridges under our belts, before taking $27M in funding and converting to C. My current LLC earns 7 figures a year. In both, we did things that were quite complex, and being an LLC made them easy compared to being an S.

In my experience, your comments are exactly backwards.

Re:Ask HN: How to structure an LLC for giving out equity by gte910h on Saturday April 16, 2011 @11:50AM (#2454155)
Why is an LLC filing as an S-Corp a ripoff compared to an actual LLC? I was advised to that particular form of business by tax professionals and would like to hear why you think they are deficient.

Now if you're just talking as compared to a disregarded entity LLC, I would agree with you

Re:Ask HN: How to structure an LLC for giving out equity by jasonkolb on Saturday April 16, 2011 @12:43PM (#2454276)
Please see my other answer, I went into pretty good detail.
Re:Ask HN: How to structure an LLC for giving out equity by gte910h on Saturday April 16, 2011 @01:00PM (#2454308)