News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Windows Server vulnerability requires immediate attention by rbanffy on Saturday September 19, 2020 @07:34PM (#24530991)
> You’re missing the biggest reason this is relevant: enterprise IT shops with strict change management processes amd, especially in government, years of austerity budgets cutting resources for both sysadmins and rigorous testing.

What's worse?

a) Deploying a fix and (unlikely) some, perhaps all, related systems fail until they are fixed internally or

b) Not deploying a fix and have your servers owned by an adversary?

Re:Windows Server vulnerability requires immediate attention by cm2187 on Saturday September 19, 2020 @08:01PM (#24531081)
Both are low probability/high impact. I don't expect a typical company to expose its domain controller to the WAN. And if the domain controller is down because of a botched update, pretty much everything else in the organisation is down. Not clear to me which one is worse.
Re:Windows Server vulnerability requires immediate attention by freehunter on Sunday September 20, 2020 @11:33AM (#24534575)
You’re absolutely right in every regard, I just want to throw in a little flavor from my experience as a security consultant. I’ve worked with state governments where we had to tune out alerting of failed logins on their domain controller because the public login for their public facing site was backed directly by their internal Active Directory server and we were seeing thousands of failed login alerts every day.

The state of infosec is still that bad and unfortunately most consumers can’t know of these problems let alone choose to opt out. Right now much of the cost of a breach is borne by the end users who didn’t choose the poor level of security the organization implemented, and I am increasingly of the opinion that it’s better to bring down your organization’s IT infrastructure than to suffer a catastrophic breach. Because if the pain if borne by the internal IT teams more than the end user (who again often has no knowledge or no choice), eventually the company will be forced to implement better processes.

As long as the real cost of a breach is paid for by end users, organizations have very little incentive to improve.

Re:Windows Server vulnerability requires immediate attention by nemosaltat on Saturday September 19, 2020 @08:40PM (#24531218)
Thanks, I feel that’s an unpopular opinion for purist, but very real for most people’s day-to-day .
Re:Windows Server vulnerability requires immediate attention by rbanffy on Sunday September 20, 2020 @10:42AM (#24534331)
I'm not sure the second one is so low probability. While the domain controller is not exposed to an external network, it is still exposed to the workstations.
Re:Windows Server vulnerability requires immediate attention by WarOnPrivacy on Saturday September 19, 2020 @11:48PM (#24531752)
Good on you for framing this in a realistic way.
Re:Windows Server vulnerability requires immediate attention by acdha on Saturday September 19, 2020 @09:43PM (#24531420)
I’d second cm2187’s general “it depends” and also note that in the environment I was describing this decision isn’t happening in a vacuum. The policy was probably set 15 years ago when someone updated a printer driver and after the production systems were back up someone chewed out the IT manager and said their job was on the line if it happened again. Now you need the CIO to approve updates and have a lengthy delay before touching core infrastructure. Sure, you can request an emergency waiver but that’s a lot of work, it’s frowned upon, and sitting on this patch probably won’t cause problems since this happens fairly often…

What the CISA memo does is change that dynamic: now most of the government has instructions to act and it’s thus personally riskier not to act promptly.

Re:Windows Server vulnerability requires immediate attention by lr on Sunday September 20, 2020 @08:38AM (#24533662)
You assume these organizations are filled with developers. From working for government, state higher ed, and health care for over 20 years, I can tell you, they are not. They are filled with techs who know how to call vendors (or are required to by leadership). So, when Epic (the EMR) system breaks and doctors and nurses can’t look up the info for an unconscious patient and the patient ends up dying, then yeah, the IT shop takes forever to patch things.