News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by skohan on Saturday September 19, 2020 @08:13AM (#24526901)
So I read somewhere that 40+% of all investors are currently leveraged, which seems like an insane figure given the recent influx of "Robinhood investors" into the market. It makes me wonder: who's on the hook if all these unsophisticated investors get wiped out?

For a lot of these investors, it will be catastrophic to their personal finances, and this might have knock-on effects on landlords for example when these people can't make rent.

Presumably this would also result in a lot of bankruptcies, and if that is the case who is on the hook for all that debt? Probably credit card companies, mortgage lenders, but what I don't know is who is the owner of the debt for leveraged trading? Is that the brokerage themselves? Is it banks? Someone else?

Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by dmurray on Saturday September 19, 2020 @08:39AM (#24527014)
> 40+% of all investors are currently leveraged, which seems like an insane figure

This does sound insanely high given how many investors have passive portfolios. I'm guessing "leveraged" means something closer to "owns at least one option" than "would be wiped out in a 25% market correction".

As for people not being able to make rent if their investments go bad, there aren't many people who are paying their rent out of their personal savings and relying on their investments. Most people work, pay rent out of their earnings, and if they're lucky put some of the excess into savings or brokerage accounts. People with larger savings are likely to own their own home.

Of course, if there's a market downturn this will lead to bankruptcies, rent defaults and a knock on effect on landlords, lenders, etc. But the main causal method there is people losing their jobs, not their savings.

Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by skohan on Saturday September 19, 2020 @08:52AM (#24527089)
> I'm guessing "leveraged" means something closer to "owns at least one option" than "would be wiped out in a 25% market correction".

I hope so, but do we know this? My understanding is that apps like Robinhood make it very easy to do options trading, and there's a whole online subculture around this type of trading.

Can we actually rule out the possibility that a non-trivial percentage of the recent run-up of the stock market is based on "dumb money" from unsophisticated investors, much of which they may not actually have?

edit:

Also I just searched Robin-hood options trading on youtube and this video was the second result:

https://youtu.be/EQRLRYvRYOM?t=568

I find the UI effect when he finishes the option buy to be very telling, and it's interesting to think about who the intended audience of this content is.

Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by edoceo on Saturday September 19, 2020 @09:01AM (#24527137)
Bloomberg thinks 20% of the market is retail

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-09-15/big-inves...

I don't think we can rule out dumb money. But also, it's not just retail who's dumb.

Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by quickthrowman on Saturday September 19, 2020 @10:26AM (#24527644)
> It makes me wonder: who's on the hook if all these unsophisticated investors get wiped out?

If they’re borrowing on margin, a correction happens, and they get a margin call they can’t pay and end up negative, they owe the money to the brokerage. It’s like any other debt that can be bought or sold, I assume.

Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by edoceo on Saturday September 19, 2020 @10:34AM (#24527682)
And that debt gets packaged and bundled and resold
Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by AYBABTME on Saturday September 19, 2020 @10:31AM (#24527669)
What happens when too many people that owe money to the brokerage go bankrupt?
Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by quickthrowman on Saturday September 19, 2020 @10:46AM (#24527758)
Well, hopefully the brokerage’s risk department prevents that! If too many people went bankrupt and owed margin debt and the brokerage went under, the government would step in and take custody of securities and cash and get them back to the holders, (at some point) who may or may not take a loss if they’re over SIPCs coverage limits of 250,000 cash and 500,000 of securities.
Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by skohan on Saturday September 19, 2020 @11:06AM (#24527876)
> Well, hopefully the brokerage’s risk department prevents that!

Blind-spots do exist, as we have seen in 2008. I'm not saying that I know better, but we can't take it for granted that these organizations have an accurate assessment of all the risks, especially when they are making record profits.

Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by quickthrowman on Sunday September 20, 2020 @10:39AM (#24534309)
> Blind-spots do exist, as we have seen in 2008. I'm not saying that I know better, but we can't take it for granted that these organizations have an accurate assessment of all the risks, especially when they are making record profits.

Absolutely! IB got caught with their pants down when /CL (WTI crude futures contract) went negative in April. Their system used to calculate margin requirements did not take negative contract prices into account, and neither did the trading software. Margin calls were not issued at the proper time, and traders couldn’t see the price or execute a trade on IB while the contract value was negative. Due to the latter, IB ended up absorbing any losses incurred by customers while /CL was negative. They lost around $110 million.

https://www.ft.com/content/01ee0794-158f-40c5-8bb9-82cf5d5f3...

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-05-08/oil-crash...

Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by mcguire on Saturday September 19, 2020 @10:43AM (#24527734)
They have insurance.

What happens if the insurance system goes bankrupt?

Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by parsimo2010 on Saturday September 19, 2020 @10:51AM (#24527796)
No they don't. The average person's insurance doesn't cover bad stock performance, the only insurance against bad trades is adjusting the beta of your portfolio. What happens when a main street investor gets hit by a crash, depending on how bad the crash is, is that they lose their savings. If they actually end up with debt that they can't repay, they may lose their house (if they own one), declare bankruptcy, and have their credit ruined for several years.
Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by MiroF on Saturday September 19, 2020 @11:00AM (#24527848)
> 40+% of all investors

Nope, no remote way that's true. 40% of all retail investors that were surveyed by a poll that probably misses out on people with retirement accounts, etc. self-reported being "leveraged." I'm not 100% confident that the general American public would be able to identify what leverage is/if they are actually leveraged.

Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by mxschumacher on Saturday September 19, 2020 @11:19AM (#24527976)
Agree, in addition it is helpful to observe relative weightings. A retail investor with 50k and 2x leverage has less impact than one 100bn+ fund that isn't borrowing
Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by gruez on Saturday September 19, 2020 @10:32AM (#24527670)
They won't get wiped out because the Fed's going to prop up the stock market at any sign of trouble.
Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by freehunter on Saturday September 19, 2020 @10:46AM (#24527760)
I live in a Northern US state and we have a saying about four-wheel drive in the snow and ice: your car won’t slide as often, but when it does it will be disastrous. Every winter you see the ditch filled with pickup trucks and SUVs who have four or all wheel drive. Usually so deep in the ditch that they need a tow truck. Most of the two-wheel drive vehicles get stuck on the shoulder, where a simple shovel could easily free them.

The Fed can keep the market from going down, and they can keep it afloat for a long time. But all that energy builds up like a rubber band, until it snaps. The stock market is going up even though it has no reason to be going up. Which means valuations are higher than they would normally be, and keep going up even though they should be flat or going down. Usually this would be fixed through minor “corrections” like maybe a quarter or two of sliding prices and then quickly back to stability and growth again.

But the longer we refuse to let nature find its equilibrium, the more catastrophic the eventual reset will be.

Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by MiroF on Saturday September 19, 2020 @10:57AM (#24527832)
> But the longer we refuse to let nature find its equilibrium, the more catastrophic the eventual reset will be.

What is this "equilibrium"? Why does the Fed taking a super contractionary policy stance seem better to you?

Expenditures are rebounding and personal income is at an all time high - both of which seem like pretty obvious reasons why stock prices are not crashing.

Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by freehunter on Saturday September 19, 2020 @11:26AM (#24528038)
The equilibrium is wherever “the market” decides it is. With the Fed pumping trillions of dollars into the market and dropping rates to 0% for extended periods of time, that’s not “the market”, that’s just the Fed.

And I’m not just talking about now, at this moment. It goes all the way back to 2008, when rates dropped to near-zero and didn’t even break 3% before they had to drop to near-zero again for the next recession (right now). The Fed gave up almost all their normal tools and never asked for them back, and now they’re gone. Which means if the economy gets worse (and staying the same as right now for an extended period of time is the same as “getting worse”), there’s not a whole lot anyone can do about it.

Basically, if the Fed is out of tools already, the only thing the Fed can do is cash injections. Which they’ve already done this year, trillions of dollars worth. And that might keep the market afloat for another year or two or ten... all while the stock market keeps going up. Not because investors think these businesses are worth that much, but because they know there will never be a decline in the market overall.

And what happens when the market becomes completely decoupled from the value of the businesses they’re trading? And better question... what happens when the Fed changes their mind?

Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by MiroF on Saturday September 19, 2020 @11:34AM (#24528110)
> The equilibrium is wherever “the market” decides it is

Remind me the last time "the market" decided on an equilibrium without the Fed. 1912?

> The Fed gave up almost all their normal tools and never asked for them back, and now they’re gone. Which means if the economy gets worse (and staying the same as right now for an extended period of time is the same as “getting worse”), there’s not a whole lot anyone can do about it.

Despite its popularity as a talking point, there is actually little economic evidence that Fed policy becomes ineffective at the zero bound. Nor really any evidence that the Fed is "out of tools."

There is huge empirical evidence that taking a expansionary stance during a recession helps lessen the impact of the recession and lower unemployment.

Why would it be better for the Fed to take a contractionary approach during a recession? So the stock market better reflects how you feel it should look?

Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by freehunter on Saturday September 19, 2020 @12:06PM (#24528399)
You’re right, the Fed is supposed to help stabilize the market. But their current position of “never let it crash” is unprecedented and dangerous.

It’s not about a “feeling” and it’s not a “contractionary approach”. My concern is the Fed has taken the position that the stock market must always go up, no matter what. It’s like saying we must never allow wildfires... well eventually something will happen outside of your control and now the entire west coast is burning and there’s nothing you can do to stop it. If you just let the smaller fires burn when they wanted/needed to, we wouldn’t be in that situation.

You seem to be drawing a hard black and white line, that either the Fed does nothing or they do everything imaginable. As always, there is a middle ground... let the market make its corrections and if something big happens then step in and help ease the pain. The problem with the “do anything and everything to make sure the market NEVER goes down” approach is at some point it will. At some point something will happen that scares investors and the market will drop faster than the Fed can print money. And the more out of touch the markets are, the harder it will drop and the more painful it will be.

But even if the eventual crash never comes, if the Fed is willing to print trillions of dollars every year to keep the stock market up, is it really even a stock market? At that point it’s just a high-interest savings account for the ultra-rich, paid for by inflation (which hurts everyone who doesn’t own stocks). And the way that ends is the rich get richer until we end up with an oligarchy.

It’s dangerous and unprecedented for the Fed to say they will keep printing unlimited amounts of money [2] in order to make sure the markets never go down. Their job is to prevent a depression, not prevent Wall Street from losing even a single dollar.

[1] https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/interest-rate

[2] https://www.marketwatch.com/story/fed-announces-unlimited-qe...

Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by skohan on Saturday September 19, 2020 @11:02AM (#24527859)
> personal income is at an all time high

What's this figure? Mean income? Median? Inflation adjusted? Is investment income included in that figure?

Not all the indicators are rosy right? I mean unemployment, and failure to make rent payments are both still abnormally high as far as I understand.

Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by MiroF on Saturday September 19, 2020 @11:08AM (#24527893)
Disposable personal income: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/DSPI

> is investment income included in that figure

Probably, but it's not a significant reason behind the recent rise.

> unemployment

Yes, unemployment is high which is why it is critical that the Fed is doing what it is doing now, while both employment and inflation are very low.

> failure to make rent payments are both still abnormally high

This metric is not really safe to look at to compare to 2019, given eviction/rent moratoriums.

Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by skohan on Saturday September 19, 2020 @11:23AM (#24528017)
> given eviction/rent moratoriums.

But this is much more of a short-term band-aid than a real solution isn't it? As I understood the eviction moratorium is just a block preventing people from being removed from their homes. It's not rent forgiveness. So when it expires, those renters will still be on the hook for months worth of back rent, and assuming a lot of them are unable to pay because they are unemployed, this just seems like we're inflating a debt bubble to be dealt with later.

That's also ignoring the financial obligations of landlords - they might also be running into trouble due to lost revenue and for now I suppose they are just supposed to bear it.

Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by MiroF on Saturday September 19, 2020 @11:30AM (#24528082)
> But this is much more of a short-term band-aid than a real solution isn't it?

My point is that you can't compare rent payment rates from when you would get evicted if you didn't pay rent to rent payment rates from an eviction moratorium where there is no penalty for not paying rent.

> they might also be running into trouble due to lost revenue and for now I suppose they are just supposed to bear it.

The reason that landlords make the profits they do is because they're taking on this kind of risk. They are the party to bear it, and have hopefully hedged in some way. If they are overexposed, then yes, they will fail. Hopefully we don't make the same too big to fail mistake we made last time.

I'm not claiming that everything is great with our economy. It's obviously not. But suggesting the Fed stop doing what it is doing would be perhaps the single worst thing you could do to the entire economy. It is good that equity prices remain high and it is good that personal income has risen. We should capitalize on those trends so that people can soon go back to work.

Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by skohan on Saturday September 19, 2020 @12:33PM (#24528602)
I'm not saying the fed should stop what they're doing, but there are certainly alternatives which might have lead to a better result. For instance, in other countries, more of the government assistance was directed to maintaining payroll and to actually support rent payments rather than just delaying that obligation. It's hard for me to understand why that would not be a better approach to stabilizing the economy compared to what happened in the US.

It seems that the actual result of QE has been that a huge percentage of that money has been dumped into equities, driving prices higher. Yes it's better than a total economic collapse, but it's not clear to me that this is actually a good thing, and not just an artificially inflated indicator which is essentially papering over very real risks to the economy which could cause massive issues down the road.

Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by MiroF on Saturday September 19, 2020 @12:40PM (#24528658)
> the government assistance was directed to maintaining payroll and to actually support rent payments

There was substantial action towards both of those ends, more than any other country.

Other countries are not really as comparable because we're the only rich developed country to have failed so badly at containing it (early on, in the next few months some of Europe will follow us).

> delaying that obligation

Delaying the obligation is better because it means that people won't be evicted if they can't meet the payments even with the governmental support. I'll be honest - the landlords aren't my principal concern here.

> papering over very real risks to the economy which could cause massive issues down the road.

What massive issues? I agree that Fed actions impact equity prices, I disagree that that is a bad thing for the economy. If we had an equity price crash along with what we're experiencing, we would be in deep, deep recession by now.

Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by skohan on Saturday September 19, 2020 @01:21PM (#24528998)
> There was substantial action towards both of those ends, more than any other country.

I just don't think that's true. From what I understand, they payroll support was extremely difficult to get for small businesses, and the majority went to large corporations who had the connections and the bandwidth to deal with the bureaucracy. Even the Cares checks took weeks to arrive in the hands of people without direct deposit.

By contrast, I am currently living in Germany, and I have friends who are freelancers and they had support funds in their bank accounts less than a week after the lockdown started. Also there was already legal machinery in place to avoid job losses which was put in place in 2008 and activated almost immediately.

> Other countries are not really as comparable because we're the only rich developed country to have failed so badly at containing it (early on, in the next few months some of Europe will follow us).

We will have to see, but I'm doubtful this is the case. In Germany for example we still have aggressive contract tracing, and we've already seen containment measures implemented successfully. We have not seen the particular failures in leadership which occurred in the US, and though we may indeed see a second wave, I'm not sure why we should expect that to go worse now that there's improved information and the population has already dealt with this once I'm not sure why we should expect this to go worse the second time.

> Delaying the obligation is better because it means that people won't be evicted if they can't meet the payments even with the governmental support

Why are these options mutually exclusive? You could provide direct support to tenants and also prevent evictions. This would limit the extent to which you are creating a future financial obligation which out-of-work tenants will have no way of meeting.

> I agree that Fed actions impact equity prices, I disagree that that is a bad thing for the economy.

I never said rising equity prices were a bad thing for the economy. My concern is that if we optimize the recovery effort for increasing equity prices, but fail to address other risks, like lack of employment and the creation of housing debt, we could be setting ourselves up for failure in the medium term. If we managed to keep people employed and in their homes and also saw rising equity prices I would have no such concern.

Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by MiroF on Saturday September 19, 2020 @01:45PM (#24529177)
> By contrast, I am currently living in Germany, and I have friends who are freelancers and they had support funds in their bank accounts less than a week after the lockdown started. Also there was already legal machinery in place to avoid job losses which was put in place in 2008 and activated almost immediately.

Every tax payer got paid $1200. You're right that it took weeks to come and was inefficient, but paired with an eviction moratorium I think mitigated the impact of the delay. The PPP had issues, but I think the money did keep unemployment lower.

That said, I'm not disputing that the German model for fiscal stimulus is better: it is. But I don't think there was a huge failure of fiscal stimulus in the US.

> Why are these options mutually exclusive? You could provide direct support to tenants and also prevent evictions

Agreed, I don't think those are mutually exclusive and I don't think more fiscal support to tenants would be a bad thing at all. I thought you were suggesting doing such instead of moratoriums, which seems unjust to me.

> My concern is that if we optimize the recovery effort for increasing equity prices, but fail to address other risks, like lack of employment and the creation of housing debt, we could be setting ourselves up for failure in the medium term

I don't think we are optimizing recovery efforts for increasing equity prices. I think that in the short-term higher equity prices is a consequence of expansionary monetary policy with a goal of reducing unemployment.

I don't think we're seeing a housing debt crisis right now and the actions the Fed is currently taking are meant to reduce unemployment (which is higher than it should be right now).

Re:The age-old strategy of buying cheap shares is faltering by Invictus0 on Saturday September 19, 2020 @12:48PM (#24528714)
It's like you haven't just seen stocks tumble 20% in the last couple weeks.