Re:US bans WeChat, TikTok from app stores, threatens shutdowns
by dragonwriter on Friday September 18, 2020 @05:28PM
(#24522055)
> Seems pretty clear that this does not apply to actions of the commerce department because they are not a legislature
Right. The executive declaring guilt and imposing criminal punishment would just be a violation of the 5th Amendment due process clause. But this isn't declaring guilt and imposing punishment, it's, superficially at leaat, making a finding delegated to the President by Congress under law designed to regulate foreign trade for the purpose of protecting national security.
Whether it comports with the detailed requirements of the authorizing law, whether the law as a whole or this specific action citing it violate the Constitution, and a number of other things may be reasonable questions, but this whole “bill of attainder” thing isn't on a number of levels.
Right. The executive declaring guilt and imposing criminal punishment would just be a violation of the 5th Amendment due process clause. But this isn't declaring guilt and imposing punishment, it's, superficially at leaat, making a finding delegated to the President by Congress under law designed to regulate foreign trade for the purpose of protecting national security.
Whether it comports with the detailed requirements of the authorizing law, whether the law as a whole or this specific action citing it violate the Constitution, and a number of other things may be reasonable questions, but this whole “bill of attainder” thing isn't on a number of levels.