News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why higher education is in trouble, in one graph by jff on Friday April 15, 2011 @03:07PM (#2451726)
What is it with HN and its continual, deathless drive to prove higher education is worthless? Christ, OK, some of you dropped out of college, that's fine, you're doing alright these days. You all don't need to keep posting this kind of shit to make up for your own feelings of inadequacy.
Re:Why higher education is in trouble, in one graph by HedgeMage on Friday April 15, 2011 @03:39PM (#2451864)
Okay, there probably are a couple of HN readers wandering around feeling inadequate about their lack of degrees. I, for one, have a different motive when I upvote the "college is broken" posts (well, the ones I like enough to upvote).

I'm tired of meeting smart people who completely lack useful skills (and have been "educated" out of the ability to acquire them on the fly without hand-holding) and need ridiculous salaries (that they don't have the skills to justify) in order to service ridiculous college debt. It's just sad.

We had another one on HN recently asking what to do with his mountain of debt and unprofitable degree. I meet about two a month, and I don't spend that much time around recent graduates.

Yes, some people leave their degree program without unmanageable debt and having gained enough to make the sacrifices worth it. However, they are in the minority.

In America, getting a degree is held out to all students as a panacea. It's even illegal to take a special needs child off the college track before age 16, regardless of how unlikely it is that that child can benefit from university study, or how much the child needs other types of education. For the bright, it's worse: high schools are graded on how many of their graduates go on to college, so the pressure can be incredibly intense even when college is an incredibly bad fit for the student.

People who don't think that university study, as most commonly implemented in the US today, is the One Right Way for all individuals, are usually shouted down as unambitious or not contributing to the economy. Entrepreneurship communities are among the few places that students can find an attitude of "do what has the most value to you, and be skeptical of anything that involves mountains of debt -- it takes a lot of earning power to service that debt and live at the same time" from a group of people whom no one can rightly call unambitious.

[deleted]
Re:Why higher education is in trouble, in one graph by ColinWright on Friday April 15, 2011 @04:37PM (#2452102)
You can edit for up to 2 hours - go fix it!
Re:Why higher education is in trouble, in one graph by TomOfTTB on Friday April 15, 2011 @03:28PM (#2451821)
Perhaps the problem is people like you who are so convinced of the infallibility of Higher Education that you assume there must be some illogical reason for criticizing it. So we have to keep hammering the point.

Or perhaps it's that many of us realize traditional higher education is no longer working. After suffering through endless interviews with college graduates that only have basic math skills despite graduating from a good university with a 4.0 it has become clear there's a huge problem here.

(For the record I'm a college graduate and a huge supporter of accredited new media Universities like Western Governors University)

Re:Why higher education is in trouble, in one graph by kevin_morrill on Friday April 15, 2011 @03:48PM (#2451906)
Well I am also sick of subsidizing student loans and skyrocketing k-12 education costs in my tax dollars. It would be a different matter if people had to truly put their money where their mouth is on this one.