News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by smokeyj on Friday April 15, 2011 @02:30PM (#2451576)
> Constitutional law is so much more complicated than, "this is what the document says".

If you can't read the document and deduce it's meaning, why use this document? Is this an emperors clothe type of thing?

Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by rauljara on Friday April 15, 2011 @02:53PM (#2451660)
If you actually read the document, you would see that the document includes provisions for a court system under the very correct assumption that some people would read the document and come to different conclusions about just what the document means.

Ever played a board game and had people disagreed on what the rules said. If you play games of any complexity, it happens all the time. Life is considerably more difficult than any game.

Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by btilly on Friday April 15, 2011 @10:18PM (#2452979)
If you actually read the document, you would see that the document includes provisions for a court system under the very correct assumption that some people would read the document and come to different conclusions about just what the document means.

The document does have a court system, but if you read it closely you'll realize that nowhere in it does it say that the courts have the ability to rule on the constitutionality of anyone else's actions, nor does it say what the courts can do if the constitution is violated. That was a power that the courts themselves decided that they had. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marbury_v._Madison for details.

Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by anigbrowl on Saturday April 16, 2011 @01:37AM (#2453285)
Yes, but that decision was grounded in the courts' enumerated powers and strangely nobody has seen fit to overturn it by amendment despite having a whole 2 centuries in which to do so.
Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by tel on Saturday April 16, 2011 @01:42PM (#2454401)
So if you realize you made a mistake 2 centuries ago it's absolutely too late to fix it?
Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by anigbrowl on Sunday April 17, 2011 @05:32AM (#2455849)
There was no mistake, in my view.
Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by smokeyj on Friday April 15, 2011 @05:53PM (#2452360)
if the Monopoly instructions read "if any questions arise, ask the Banker, his word is final", I would not play that game.
Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by fjh on Friday April 15, 2011 @06:49PM (#2452519)
That's more or less what the rules for any Pen&Paper RPG and lots of different sports (e.g. soccer) say.
Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by mbreese on Friday April 15, 2011 @07:16PM (#2452576)
Case in point: when I was younger and played soccer, we had one ref who before the game would go over rules with us. Invariably, he'd ask us what offsides was. A younger kid would always give him the book answer for the league: being ahead of the ball with less than two defenders between you and the goal (goalie counts as one). He'd quickly then say "no! offsides is this." and point to his whistle. The point was very clear... He had the final call on what was offsides, so there was no use complaining if we had a different opinion.

He was actually a quite fair ref.

Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by dgordon on Friday April 15, 2011 @09:59PM (#2452954)
Yep, as anyone who watched the World Cup learned: see the phantom foul (no one even knows who it was allegedly on) that took away the US victory over Slovenia, or the referee denying a game-tying goal by England against Germany that the whole stadium got to see on replay, to which FIFA's response was to ban replay from the rest of the World Cup.

It's not good in sports and it's far worse in government.

Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by samfoo on Friday April 15, 2011 @02:42PM (#2451621)
Because the world is a complicated place where a single (short) document is unlikely to fairly represent anything other than guiding principles. Having guiding principles is hugely important and valuable, just as giving people the leeway to make judgement calls on those principles is. Justice shouldn't be black and white.
Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by smokeyj on Friday April 15, 2011 @03:06PM (#2451720)
If constitutionality can't be deduced by the constitution, then what deduces it? The opinion of some judges?

If our fate is in the hands of a few judges (it is), doesn't this void our "democratic principles"?

I can't help but feel our understanding of government isn't much more than catch phrases and sentiment. Patriotism, we the people, one nation under god, the greater good, public servants, all total bs. If we criticized the processes of government like we did start-ups (such as the costs of value added), we'd be a whole lot wealthier. /rant

Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by Locke1689 on Friday April 15, 2011 @03:49PM (#2451910)
Your rant is misguided and childish. The law is dynamic because it must be applied in areas where no prior written text has a straightforward conclusion.

A simple example is wiretapping laws. Because of historical stare decisis interpretations of the Constitution, it is ruled a violation of the 4th Amendment for the government to wiretap a citizen without a court order. Nowhere in the Constitution is this protection written -- it required the application of the spirit of the document to the 20th century by the Supreme Court.

Fortunately, we don't need to bicker about this because you seem to hold the Constitution as the preeminent law of the land. Since the Constitution is correct by definition (according to you) and it gives the Supreme Court jurisdiction over its interpretation, the Supreme Court is also correct by definition.

Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by smokeyj on Friday April 15, 2011 @04:18PM (#2452041)
> you seem to hold the Constitution as the preeminent law of the land

To the contrary, my point is this document is ambiguous and subject to interpretation. So, who interprets it? The judges of course! The very people this document is supposed to protect me from. Seems a bit circular. Fast forward to year 2012, and judges say it's OK to seize domain names. How can the constitution defend my right to free speech and also defend the government's right to seize domains?

Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by Locke1689 on Saturday April 16, 2011 @01:20AM (#2453248)
Fast forward to year 2012, and judges say it's OK to seize domain names.

Then it's Constitutional by definition. Congress, however, can pass a law amending the Constitution to prohibit the seizure of domain names. Then it's no longer Constitutional. Do they not teach the three branches of government or checks and balances in middle school anymore?

Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by chronomex on Saturday April 16, 2011 @03:06AM (#2453446)
Congress cannot amend the constitution as easily as it can pass a law. The States have to agree to it as well.
Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by Locke1689 on Saturday April 16, 2011 @03:33AM (#2453482)
Yeah. It's the Constitution. It's supposed to be hard to change.
Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by yoyar on Friday April 15, 2011 @08:23PM (#2452761)
yes, who watches the watchers?
Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by ugh on Saturday April 16, 2011 @02:03AM (#2453333)
Ever heard of separation of powers? Three branches of government?
Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by smokeyj on Saturday April 16, 2011 @12:04PM (#2454195)
Remind me, who was declaring war reserved for?
Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by shasta on Saturday April 16, 2011 @12:22AM (#2453161)
"and it gives the Supreme Court jurisdiction over its interpretation"

[citation needed]

Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by Locke1689 on Saturday April 16, 2011 @01:14AM (#2453242)
"The judicial Power of the United States, shall be vested in one supreme Court, and in such inferior Courts as the Congress may from time to time ordain and establish. The Judges, both of the supreme and inferior Courts, shall hold their Offices during good Behavior, and shall, at stated Times, receive for their Services a Compensation which shall not be diminished during their Continuance in Office."
Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by shasta on Saturday April 16, 2011 @01:55AM (#2453323)
Right. Where's the bit about determining the constitutionality of laws? It's not spelled out
Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by Locke1689 on Saturday April 16, 2011 @03:44AM (#2453493)
Just read Marbury v. Madison. I have no more time for a 5th grade civics lesson.
Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by shasta on Saturday April 16, 2011 @06:46AM (#2453714)
You should have revisited the situation after fifth grade. Fifth grade teachers like to simplify things. Marbury introduced judicial review. It's not in the constitution.
Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by Locke1689 on Sunday April 17, 2011 @04:45AM (#2455803)
Good thing I never mentioned judicial review, right? Appellate reviews satisfies my statement just fine. Also, while judicial review did become reinforced after Marbury v. Madison, you'll note that the power was derived from an interpretation of the Constitution, not the court itself. That the Constitution implies judicial review is in purview of SCOTUS is a long-accepted interpretation of the Constitution.
Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by shasta on Sunday April 17, 2011 @10:47AM (#2456216)
The idea that the courts have jurisdiction over the interpretation of the constitution (as opposed to, say, each branch being independently obligated to adhere to the constitution) is judicial review, not appellate review.
Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by nika on Friday April 15, 2011 @03:52PM (#2451928)
You called him misguided and childish. You lose the argument.
Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by nika on Friday April 15, 2011 @02:56PM (#2451674)
I don't think anyone denies that there are areas where the constitution is not sufficiently detailed. However, the constitution still says what it says, and many actions that are considered "legal" today do not fall into the areas of constitutional vagueness, but are simply laws that violate the constitution that have never been sufficiently challenged.

The constitution is pretty black and white, and this is a good thing, because it means you can tell what is set out by it, and what is up to the legislature.

All the areas where the constitution enumerated powers it gave the legislature a free hand to determine what is right.

Thus for the areas that the constitution does address, it is pretty black and white and it is meant to be enforced by the people.

... and it really isn't hard to understand, nor does it require much interpretation. Just careful reading.

Re:FBI seized PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, UB.com,... ... by anigbrowl on Saturday April 16, 2011 @01:34AM (#2453279)
If you can't read the document and deduce it's meaning, why use this document? Is this an emperors clothe type of thing?

Why teach the illiterate to read? What good are words if people need teachers to explain them?