Re:21 years after the request OpenPGP support gets added to ...
by kd5bjo on Thursday September 17, 2020 @08:04PM
(#24511452)
For future reference, statements like this:
> I used to love [A], but I now think [B] is a bad idea.
will lead many people to think that you consider A and B to be essentially the same thing. In the specific case of PGP and encrypted email, this is a category error: you are implying (perhaps unintentionally) that PGP’s only use is for encrypted email.
I agree that one great weakness of Signal is its centralization, and that decentralization is a great strength of email.
For a decentralized encrypted communication channel, Matrix may become a good option now that it is encrypted by default, but I haven't studied carefully the quality of its encryption beyond that yet.
Regardless, I really do think a new protocol is required for secure communications and that email won't cut it. If Signal or Matrix can't do the job for some applications, we'll just have to try again. I cannot recommend email for secure communications, and in any situation where security matters, I have to prioritize people's safety. In terms of security, the best that is available in the realm of encrypted email is not and cannot be good enough.