News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Still Need Howard Zinn by rayiner on Thursday September 17, 2020 @06:09PM (#24510583)
Because it’s not the truth, and is in fact propaganda. There was a purpose to it back when it was published, because it was a response to books that were also propaganda. But there is no place for it today, where better scholarship exists and the Internet provides ready access to a plethora of view points.
Re:We Still Need Howard Zinn by tmh79 on Thursday September 17, 2020 @06:26PM (#24510728)
>>> "But there is no place for it today, where better scholarship exists and the Internet provides ready access to a plethora of view points"

Thats now how history works at all man. Pretty much all writing on history goes into the metaphorical dust bin maybe 20-40 years after it is created but the "dust bin" isn't a dead place that no one should ever explore, its the world of historiography, and understanding how people understood their point in time at different points in time. No one should read a history book like its the bible handed down from on high, they should read it knowing the authors biases, the contemporary views on the authors work from other experts in the field, and an understanding of their own knowledge level and context. The reality is that a huge amount of K-12 American history education is propaganda and for someone with a K-12 American history background this book is a very compelling read that provides a useful counter narrative to what they have been taught, the main function of which is not to blindly trust the words in the book, but to understand the practice of history not as a recitation of facts but an analysis of past events with a specific point of view, and how different points of view from authors with different motivations can give different views of the past. IMO, this really brought the field of history to life for me.

Re:We Still Need Howard Zinn by elefanten on Thursday September 17, 2020 @07:39PM (#24511275)
It seems like the spirit of your comment is in accord with GP. GGP put forth that Zinn is "the truth."

GP may have phrased it a bit dismissively but I read that comment as making the same argument you do: no given history book contains the final truth.

As for GP's comment that Zinn has no place today -- you offer a more nuanced take. But we're in a moment replete with valorizing paeans to Zinn (like TFA) and calls for using People's History more widely as a _textbook_. Maybe, given that we are 40 years on from it's writing, that's not the best move.

Re:We Still Need Howard Zinn by jolux on Thursday September 17, 2020 @06:12PM (#24510618)
Which parts of it are untrue?
Re:We Still Need Howard Zinn by tildedave on Thursday September 17, 2020 @06:21PM (#24510686)
Sorry to point you to more references, but the AskHistorians subreddit has a pretty good survey of views on the issue. https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/search?q=zinn&restric...
Re:We Still Need Howard Zinn by Kranar on Thursday September 17, 2020 @07:21PM (#24511158)
I made what I think is a good faith effort to review the link you provided, but I don't see any indication of factual errors Howard Zinn makes. It appears the criticism of him is that he is biased, he makes heavy use of secondary sources (a quantifiable claim which as best as I can tell is false given that Zinn's sources are enumerated and mostly primary) and engages in something called "presentism", which is to make moral judgements of historical acts based on modern moral standards, a claim I don't have any particular issue with but even if I did it has no bearing on the factual content of his work.

At no point have I seen anyone point out a factual error that Zinn has made, only that people don't like the conclusions he draws from those facts. Another commonly repeated point is that there are other historical works that do a better job than A People's History. That is almost certainly true as well, but that claim is no more relevant than pointing out that there are better scientific works that do a better job than Einstein's "Relativity: The Special and General Theory".

Having read A People's History, the very beginning of the book explicitly states that he is biased, that bias is something very hard to escape in almost any social study and is present among almost all historical literature whether the author admits it or not, and that the difference between his book and other historical works is that he makes the conscious decision to be biased from the point of view of the people who were conquered as opposed to writing from the point of view of the people who did the conquering.

Certainly Zinn has likely made some errors, but none of them are in the link you provided (as far as I could tell).

Re:We Still Need Howard Zinn by jahaja on Thursday September 17, 2020 @07:54PM (#24511374)
This is also very similar to the criticism Noam Chomsky have received. He has been very accurate for decades but is still handled as an outcast.

Come to think about of it actually, it's also similar with the criticism of David Graeber's (RIP) book "Debt", which usually focus on "well, he wrote something really wrong paragraph about Apple, so you can't believe anything he writes really"

Re:We Still Need Howard Zinn by UncleMeat on Thursday September 17, 2020 @07:46PM (#24511323)
> factual errors

This is not the limit of criticism of history scholarship. Braudel's Civilization and Capitalism isn't considered dated because of factual errors but instead because it over-represents a particular narrative and analysis style that fails to paint a detailed picture of things.

History scholarship is absolutely not a list of facts. It is the construction of a narrative from source material. A text that is 100% truthful to fact can still be entirely bogus scholarship (I'm not saying that Zinn's is).

Re:We Still Need Howard Zinn by jolux on Thursday September 17, 2020 @07:57PM (#24511395)
I will accuse Zinn of many things but not constructing a narrative from his facts is not one of them :)

I happen to disagree with a lot of his political opinions but I think it's very important that APHUS exists.

Re:We Still Need Howard Zinn by UncleMeat on Thursday September 17, 2020 @08:48PM (#24511778)
Sure it is a relevant book, especially in leftist history work. The problem scholars have with it is that it is held up as the text by some laypeople. It is not unique in having narrative issues. That's true of all history. It is just frustrating to see people say "well, he didn't get any facts wrong so all criticism is invalid".
Re:We Still Need Howard Zinn by jolux on Thursday September 17, 2020 @11:49PM (#24512800)
No, I would never say all criticism is invalid. I think it's a relevant and important text to read, along with criticism of it. Nothing should be taken in isolation, scholarship is ultimately a conversation at a high level between knowledgeable parties, and it's a pretty dated book in a lot of ways. Nonetheless it was extremely influential and solid as a basic leftist history text, and he even acknowledges its bias in the preface and title as I've mentioned. I don't by half think it's a perfect book and I have a lot of criticisms of Zinn.
Re:We Still Need Howard Zinn by jolux on Thursday September 17, 2020 @06:26PM (#24510729)
I ask for specifics because I know all the general arguments around it. I asked about what was specifically untrue, I have not read solid criticisms of it that cast serious doubt on its factual claims, only that it shows history from a certain perspective, which (to be fair to Zinn here) is evident in the title.
Re:We Still Need Howard Zinn by sanderjd on Thursday September 17, 2020 @07:03PM (#24511004)
Right, so go check the thread that you were linked to. It's clearly going to be a more holistic treatment than you're going to get in this thread on hacker news, a site for programmers and software entrepreneurs, not historians.
Re:We Still Need Howard Zinn by jolux on Thursday September 17, 2020 @08:01PM (#24511420)
I've read them, and I've also read Michael Kazin's criticism in particular numerous times.
Re:We Still Need Howard Zinn by sbilstein on Thursday September 17, 2020 @06:29PM (#24510750)
Quite a bit of the people's history of the united states is primary sources.

Zinn decided to bias the viewpoint towards oppressed people, the same way many textbooks bias it in favor of the 'winning' party. While I felt like I got a pretty decent education in high school history, Zinn didn't invalidate what I learned but showed quite clearly how these things affected others.

When I was in school it would have been highly controversial to compare chattel slavery or the conquering of the New World to the holocaust but the reality is the severity is similar, just on a different timeframe.

Re:We Still Need Howard Zinn by rayiner on Thursday September 17, 2020 @06:55PM (#24510955)
Except that one of the primary criticisms is that the primary sources are edited heavily and misleadingly. I have particularly little sympathy for that, because one of the things you learn as a lawyer is that using a misleading quote or omission destroys your credibility in an adversarial system like legal proceedings. Your opponent will invariably provide the missing context in response and make you look like a liar. If a history book takes liberties (for example, in one passage, using an ellipses to connect sentences in two completely different documents written two days apart) that I wouldn’t in legal practice, that’s a huge red flag.