News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nvidia Broadcast App by pjlegato on Thursday September 17, 2020 @05:42PM (#24510299)
This argument assumes that pricing is to be determined through some a priori philosophical consideration of what is "fair" or "reasonable" compensation for effort involved in creating supply, according to some subjective personal idea of what those terms mean.

Empirically, pricing is - always and everywhere - determined by the intersection of supply and demand, nothing more and nothing less. The labor theory of value and its relatives are empirically false.

Re:Nvidia Broadcast App by monadic2 on Thursday September 17, 2020 @05:57PM (#24510472)
Empirically, prices are set by the seller.
Re:Nvidia Broadcast App by pjlegato on Thursday September 17, 2020 @06:39PM (#24510828)
The seller can _ask_ for any price they like, not unilaterally "set" it.

They're only going to get that, and thus set the price, if there is also a buyer who agrees to pay that price.

In technical terms, I was using "set the price" to mean "discover the the market-clearing price that allows a transaction to happen."

Re:Nvidia Broadcast App by monadic2 on Thursday September 17, 2020 @07:43PM (#24511311)
Right, but this attitude allows neglecting any behavior that results in bad resource distribution as inevitable and immutable. That's not how economies work by all observation. Empirically supply/demand is insufficient to explain all the market behavior that's trivially observable, especially when you can easily manipulate both sides of that narrative with enough capital.

The labor theory of value certainly has issues but at the very least I would expect a critique to provide an alternative narrative of observable pricing pressures, such as scarcity and market controls. This type of reductive thinking doesn't have a clear end to my eyes.

Re:Nvidia Broadcast App by ric2b on Friday September 18, 2020 @03:57PM (#24521245)
Sure, but the seller is not guaranteed to get sales.

So there must be an agreement between the seller and the buyer on what the item is worth, and "worth" includes what alternatives both of them have available as well.