News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:This electrical transmission tower has a problem by harha on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:26AM (#24502031)
Take driving as an analogy - there's a non-zero risk of having a crash, but it's significantly higher if you don't follow the rules (drunk, speeding, broken car). This feels like PG&E was betting it wouldn't happen to them.

I think for a utility the risk should be very very close to zero, you can really do a lot of planning around it and make sure that if you're running infrastructure in a dangerous area to take sufficient measures to avoid all likely failures, and if one part breaks it doesn't end in a catastrophe. Maintenance schedules are there for a reason and keeping records helps improve the data for risk models.

But there might also be some blame on the general planning of the area, if it's too dangerous to run a power line, there shouldn't be one there. If other causes are likely, it shouldn't be unreasonable to expect this to be one of the government tasks to make sure that they set up some form of protection.

Re:This electrical transmission tower has a problem by Zanni on Thursday September 17, 2020 @04:20AM (#24502300)
An even better analogy is Jenga. California's uncontrolled fuel load was going to result in massive fires at some point. Yes, PG&E could have reduced the chance of it being them, which would be great for PG&E, but would make no difference to California.
Re:This electrical transmission tower has a problem by harha on Thursday September 17, 2020 @04:38AM (#24502404)
Yes this makes sense - back to driving, it's like a road that clearly wasn't safe to operate, but the drunk driving didn't help either.
Re:This electrical transmission tower has a problem by Retric on Thursday September 17, 2020 @07:28AM (#24503322)
The fuel load decays over time, so a long enough wait period and the next fire is independent of the last fire. Thus, fewer PG&E fires just means less fires rather than there being some independent amount of fire that’s always going to happen.

If anything they need to have more responsibility in such areas not less responsibility. If they can’t detect a tree is at risk or not then either cut down more trees or use underground power lines in that area.

Re:This electrical transmission tower has a problem by pixl97 on Thursday September 17, 2020 @10:20AM (#24504934)
This is mostly incorrect, and a really bad take at understanding fires in semi-arid climates.

The fires we are having are a human caused problem, and by human I don't necessarily mean PG&E. Trying to put this blame on one company is going to accomplish pretty much nothing and just lead to more deaths in the future as we piss around looking for the wrong people to blame and avoid solutions.

Also, underground cables still cause fires. I know this from experience.

Re:This electrical transmission tower has a problem by Retric on Thursday September 17, 2020 @10:36AM (#24505129)
Amusingly, mostly incorrect in this case translates to true. The point is it’s not a linear increase with time. Yes, controlled burns can make a serious difference, their also a significant risk on their own as unlike wetter climates you get a lot of fuel at the same time.

Blaming PG&E is relevant because they are one of the few companies operating in these areas. When fires start in suburbs they rarely grow out of control, it’s when their far from human habitation that you see major issues. Another option would be adding sensors to PG&E equipment to allow for rapid responses and thus vastly limited growth.

Underground cables still causing fires doesn’t mean much when their significantly less likely to cause wildfires.

Re:This electrical transmission tower has a problem by pixl97 on Thursday September 17, 2020 @10:51AM (#24505317)
>When fires start in suburbs they rarely grow out of control, it’s when their far from human habitation

Do you know what 'Wildland Urban Interface' means?

Do you know where most of the houses burn?

Do you understand why this is the case?

Re:This electrical transmission tower has a problem by Retric on Thursday September 17, 2020 @12:11PM (#24506426)
Yes, yes, and yes. Your point?
Re:This electrical transmission tower has a problem by 10000truths on Thursday September 17, 2020 @08:28AM (#24503770)
Well clearly, the fuel load accumulates faster than it decays, or else the fires would not have reached this scale in the first place.
Re:This electrical transmission tower has a problem by Retric on Thursday September 17, 2020 @10:47AM (#24505267)
In the short term yes, but like many things it’s an S curve.
Re:This electrical transmission tower has a problem by throw0101a on Thursday September 17, 2020 @06:58AM (#24503134)
> This feels like PG&E was betting it wouldn't happen to them.

PG&E is regulated, like most utilities are.

Where are/were the regulators?

Re:This electrical transmission tower has a problem by onetimemanytime on Thursday September 17, 2020 @04:17AM (#24502283)
>>I think for a utility the risk should be very very close to zero

They can lower the risk by a lot, but are you ready to pay 65 cents (or whatever) a KW ? PG&E, with all its faults, has been put in an impossible position: one fire (that is bound to happen no matter what because wires fail) can bankrupt them since it can burn hundreds of thousand of acres, thousands of homes, untold deaths and other property destruction.

You can't really blame them for everything. Manage forests, stop building a town in the middle of the freaking forest and raise electricity rates for a complete audit of all the lines. Otherwise, nothing can be done, just talk.

Re:This electrical transmission tower has a problem by ClumsyPilot on Thursday September 17, 2020 @06:11AM (#24502850)
I think that's a very poor argument, for a few reasons:

1) We are talking about criminal negligence, saving money is not a good reason of not dealing with crime.

2) we are talking about parts not being replaced in 100 years, the OP is not asking for some crazy level of maintenance thats going to break the bank.

3) once you take into account collateral damage and potential punitive damages, is it actually any cheaper?

4) whats the point of having cheap electricity if ut's inreliable, and ready to fail at any moment?

Re:This electrical transmission tower has a problem by lordnacho on Thursday September 17, 2020 @07:26AM (#24503304)
If 65 cents is the actual cost then it should be the price. You can't be charging people 20 cents or whatever, but then they also have to pay to have their homes rebuilt every few decades, pay for insurance, and pay for firefighters.
Re:This electrical transmission tower has a problem by pnutjam on Thursday September 17, 2020 @09:58AM (#24504667)
Don't forget, at the current rate we're all subsidizing the rural power users. They should absolutely pay more if it costs more.
Re:This electrical transmission tower has a problem by scottlamb on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:18PM (#24508767)
I think blaming rural power users is a dangerous idea for a couple reasons.

> Don't forget, at the current rate we're all subsidizing the rural power users.

I'm sure this is true to some extent—just as it is for telecommunications and mail delivery—but this tower wasn't just for rural power users, was it? I think it was some sort of high-voltage long-distance transmission line. There's a region-wide electrical grid, in part because power generation doesn't happen in city centers. Urban and suburban consumers depend on rural transmission lines.

> They should absolutely pay more if it costs more.

Rural areas produce the food urban areas need. I suppose your goal is to encourage people to move from rural areas to urban areas to lower total societal cost. Presumably you don't also want the food supply to fall and/or food insecurity to increase among the urban poor. So it'd be irresponsible to make this change without careful monitoring and matching policy changes to prevent those effects. You need to keep food affordable, to keep farming affordable, to keep providing services farmers need affordable, etc.

Re:This electrical transmission tower has a problem by pnutjam on Thursday September 17, 2020 @04:56PM (#24509855)
Rural people love their subsidies. We should encourage people to live in denser areas, not all cities, but towns. How many rural people do you think are involve in food production? It's only around 10%.
Re:This electrical transmission tower has a problem by scottlamb on Thursday September 17, 2020 @06:46PM (#24510877)
> Rural people love their subsidies. We should encourage people to live in denser areas, not all cities, but towns. How many rural people do you think are involve in food production? It's only around 10%.

I have no idea. It's a hard question to answer. You are sure with no citation so I think you're wrong.

How do you define "rural" and how do you define a "town"? The US Census—which probably was directly or indirectly the source of your 10%—defines rural as not urban. Urban clusters must have a population of 2,500, [1] which already excludes a lot of what I'd call towns. And as a spot check, I don't see Grundy Center, IA on the list, despite meeting the population requirement (and not being included in a larger urban cluster AFAIK). Maybe it fails one of their other requirements. It is in their list of "incorporated places".

How do you define "involved in food production"? If I live with my family on a farm but picked "truck driver" as my occupation, am I involved in food production? If I am a teacher to farmers' kids, in a town of 500 people (see above), am I involved in food production? etc. Farmers don't exist in a vacuum. They need services like everyone else.

Even if you are right, "only about 10%" doesn't mean you won't cause pretty significant problems for everyone by messing with those folks...

[1] https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/geography/guidance/g...

Re:This electrical transmission tower has a problem by pnutjam on Friday September 18, 2020 @08:07AM (#24515647)
I'm not saying we mess with these people, I'm saying we charge market rate, or closer to it, for electricity. Maybe setup a program they can apply for to get a subsidy. That will make the process much clearer and everyone can track how much is being subsidized.

We shouldn't just throw money at companies and hide the subsidies. The help should go to the people who ask for it and that way it's much clearer to everyone involved.

Re:This electrical transmission tower has a problem by harha on Thursday September 17, 2020 @04:36AM (#24502388)
I understand the constraints and I'm not blaming them for everything, creating this dangerous situation is also a great issue, but I think this was handled very badly on their part as well.

As a utility they should have a set of rules and guidelines on how to operate safely. If it isn't possible in a situation, they should say no to the other party. With the rules they should be able to point at exactly what is missing and get the other side to fix their part (e.g. the risk or get them to pay extra for maintenance) or stop operating that bit. This looks like they intentionally looked the other way.

Re:This electrical transmission tower has a problem by syshum on Thursday September 17, 2020 @07:03AM (#24503171)
While I am a huge supporter of free market and capitalism, due to the massive regulations on utilities it is no longer a free market, at least for power generation and delivery.

Thus the better model for utilities are Coop's, member / consumer owned businesses where the goal is delivering reliable, safe power at a reasonable rate.

Utilities by their nature lend themselves to Market Monopoly, regulations added to that almost assures it so for most people having that service provided by a member owner COOP instead of an Investor Owned corporation will result in a better safer, more reliable outcome