Re:Comparative advantage and when to blow up your island
by chii on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @08:35PM
(#24488355)
> If all you have left to fight with is improvised weapons, then it continues with that.
and see how well (or poorly) that work. Look at afganistan. Look at iraq. Insurgents continue to fight, and the usa just cannot completely win.
A war is won on ideology, not weapons.
Re:Comparative advantage and when to blow up your island
by WalterBright on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @09:18PM
(#24488602)
> Insurgents continue to fight, and the usa just cannot completely win.
The US cannot win those because it is unwilling to do what is necessary (indiscriminate killing) to win.
> A war is won on ideology, not weapons.
I don't see much evidence for that in the history of warfare. For example, during WW1, the fortunes of the armies ebbed and flowed with the ebb and flow of who had the technical advantage in the air war.
If all you have left to fight with is improvised weapons, then it continues with that.
I would argue that very expensive, complex machines are the Tiger tank mistake all over again. Mechanically unreliable because of the complexity, but when it worked it was completely unmatched. One Tiger tank defeated 50 Russian tanks in the battle of Kursk, if I remember correctly.
But the cheaper, mass produced tanks of the allies won out because they could be fielded in much greater numbers.