It really depends on where you want to spend your time starting out. I wonder how big of a pain it would be to migrate your existing customer base over to a different solution when you outgrow this one and pickup your own merchent account and payment gateway.
Chargify: $99/month flat + merchant account and gateway fees
Recurly: $69/month + .$10/transaction = $119 + merchant account and gateway fees
Subscribify: $.30/transaction = $150 plus 4%
It really depends on where you want to spend your time starting out. I wonder how big of a pain it would be to migrate your existing customer base over to a different solution when you outgrow this one and pickup your own merchent account and payment gateway.