News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Red flags I saw while doing technical interviews by duxup on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:04PM (#24482857)
IMO it's not really 'not important' as much as 'not honest'.

Someone, somewhere at that company chose to hire someone... and they know what they want them to do. Why aren't they telling me?

Here I am sitting down expecting to divulge all sorts of things / do a dance, but they can't tell me what they want...

There's all sorts of reasons to not tell anyone / corporate circumstances, but it's a really bad foot to start off with / makes me worry.

Re:Red flags I saw while doing technical interviews by pmichaud on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:33PM (#24483220)
You're probably right that sometimes people are hiding something from you. But I think a lot of the time it's more like "I have 10 people doing a bunch of things that vary over time and on a day to day basis, and what each of them does specifically really depends on what they are good at and what comes up. I really want those 10 people to be able to do 10% more of that confusing mix of activities than they are currently doing. So I guess I'll hire someone new."

And when that new person asks what they will be doing, the answer actually is, honestly, sort of ambiguous.

It's not a great sign for how organized they are, but it's still a realistic way someone could both be hiring and not know exactly what the new person's day to day will be like.

Re:Red flags I saw while doing technical interviews by duxup on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @01:21PM (#24483884)
Yeah I don't think of it as 'deceptive', but more so just not through through or even clearly sharing what the situation is.

For me "we've got like 20 things going on, here's a little about them, so that kinda stuff, but I've no idea day to day how it will play out" is actually plenty honest if that's the case.

Re:Red flags I saw while doing technical interviews by zafka on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:54PM (#24483481)
This definitely describes our R&D group.
Re:Red flags I saw while doing technical interviews by polk on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:23PM (#24483097)
>Someone, somewhere at that company chose to hire someone... and they know what they want them to do. Why aren't they telling me?

This isn't necessarily true. As a counter example, I've seen team leads who claim they need to hire more engineers in order to keep up with workload. In reality, it's a process issue, but why put in the hard work of streamlining company operations, when they can just request more people underneath them. Not only is it less effort, but they also get to say "I grew the team 2x and now manage y people" which in turn increases their compensation.

It's a case of poorly aligned incentives: managers are supposed to do more with less, but their compensation structure rewards the opposite.