Is it that clear-cut? Is a nice friendly org that considers the options and picks something minimal and ostensibly ethical like Fathom or Plausible and then just uses that to keep track of how they are doing evil? Or is that not a third party, just first-party outsourced? Not sure what definition we're working with here :)
I’m late to respond, but yes. Third party analytics allows a centralized entity to track your activity across multiple websites. No matter how privacy friendly Fathom and Plausible claim to be, I would rather not have to trust them.
Self-hosted analytics takes this out of the question.
https://www.eff.org/policy
I think that first-party analytics are kind of a gray area. Third-party analytics are always evil.