News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Research questions that could have a big social impact, o... by dragonwriter on Monday September 14, 2020 @09:58PM (#24477167)
> They are asking which questions in political science will have the biggest impact on the world as judged by a utilitarian and long-termist framework, and I don't see why political scientists would have a confident answer to that.

> Likewise, I am a physicist with expertise in what questions are of intellectual interest to physicists, but I don't think that I or my colleagues have good ready answers to which physics questions will have the biggest impact on the world.

While answering the question involves predicting the future in ways no one should be overly confident in, it's worth noting that social impact questions of that type are, in fact, within the domain of political science in a way they are not within the domain of physics, so practitioners within the two fields aren't exactly similarly situated with regard to the question.

Re:Research questions that could have a big social impact, o... by jessriedel on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @12:11PM (#24482945)
Sort of. Some political scientists are certainly more likely to estimate the impact of their policy suggestions than physicsts, mostly because physicists rarely make policy suggestions. But I don't think they try to survey all political science questions and systematically compare them along some measure of impact. I expect the hypothetically disagreement between Dafoe and a random political scientist is based on a disagreement outside the expertise (the importance and long-term impact of AI in general). Likewise, physicists wouldn't tell you much about the impact of their work because it hinges on things (e.g., econ) outside their expertise.
Re:Research questions that could have a big social impact, o... by adamsea on Tuesday September 15, 2020 @07:54PM (#24488063)
And is everything you are saying just sort of, your own take on things?

Or do you have some sort of special expertise?

Because sure, what you're saying sounds good, but it's far from a piece of ironclad logic, so, color me un-convinced : ).