Knives aren't "arbitrarily-prohibited item[s]". There's a quite famous case of a series of hijackings that were done with box-cutters (e.g. utility knives), that resulted in 3,000 dead.
That seems a little...overconfident. While some of the TSA stuff is definitely security theater that adds little value, not all of it is.
> "Arbitrarily-prohibited" was a jab at everything else they've seen fit to condemn by extension, for example pliers. It's not just knives that you have to be concerned about, but anything remotely non-basic that you otherwise keep in your backpack.
You can carry on pliers, just as long as they're less than 7 inches long:
https://www.agefotostock.com/age/en/Stock-Images/Rights-Mana...
https://www.tsa.gov/travel/security-screening/whatcanibring/...
The pair of pliers I have is 7.25 inches long. That rule seems quite reasonable to me.
They do have a difficult task: write rules that can be executed quickly by relatively low-level employees to exclude items that could be used as a weapon or be a danger to the plane. I doubt that's even possible to do without creating corner cases that someone could gripe about.
For anything that can be checked on the airplane, there should be a free miniature bag that gets added to your checked luggage.
Anything that cannot ride on the airplane but can be ground shipped should get you a free envelope to ship.
For the remaining stuff (eg bulging lithium batteries), there should be a system whereby you can leave it at the checkpoint to be picked up by someone else within the same day.
Failing all of those, disposal should be the last option.