Would you agree that a reasonable assumption that if an electronic is shipped with an AC adaptor, then that electronic will be used with it?
And CBP does not have a crystal ball:
- Are you using it as is?
- If the UL marking is fake, who is to know about the entire thing?
- Are you going to resell this? If so, is the AC adaptor going with it?
- How do they know that this was an honest mistake? Do they take the your word at face value?
I could go on and on with scenarios. I get it, that is not fun. But I will ask you, what should they have done?
Seized the adapters. That would have been enough for me to be more careful about adapters in the future. Seizing the whole shipment hurts me, but not the supplier.
See my other example here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24469959
There's any number of things you might not expect, and the receiver is the only one hurt when they are a smaller player.
The burden of truth is supposed to be on the accuser.
Consider if you will - a robber is caught by police in his own house. In this house, they found the items the robber stole. Should they:
a) take the items the robber stole b) take everything
OP is inside of the US, and probably lives here as well. He's not a flight risk, and its totally reasonable to ask them to go through slow bureaucratic means to make sure they get it right.
CBP acts like they are the first line in a war when really they ought to be helping people come into compliance, and track down bad suppliers.
Taped to the wall on the Sault Ste. Marie crossing CBP station:
"We Are The First Line Of Defense"
Why should CBP siege all the electronics if just the adapters are not legal? Sure, if the main electronics also have counterfeit UL marks then they also should be seized, but if the main electronics aren’t counterfeit why should invalid adapters be the grounds for seizing everything else?
You are "trusting" the poster here and assuming there "intentions" are good.
As far as me “trusting” OP on the story, well yeah, it’s a random HN comment. Literally nothing is at stake here. If you’re going to start assuming that OP is lying for HN cred then be my guest, but it seems needlessly paranoid to me.
They don’t know what anyone’s intentions are except to apply electrical components to solving a problem.
Should they stop all electronics shipments? Except for the Apples of the world?
Would that make you feel safer?
The occasional irrational actor isn’t as real a threat to me as my constantly paranoid neighbors and government.
If you bought something and it arrived and was a fake, would you buy from that shipper again?
Where the adapters packaged separately to make that possible? Or are you asking some customs inspector to unbox all your items, remove the adapters, and repack it all?
The only other country I could find with the products was Taiwan, and it wasn't 100% clear if they were just importing Chinese products. They were significantly more expensive.
I don't know very well how patents and intellectual property protection work... But, if there are no suppliers of such a product in the United States (assuming your previous argument as true), then what product is being pirated? if there is none (worth the redundancy), to my understanding, there has to be a vendor whose product is being counterfeited within the united states for it to be taken as an infringement of intellectual property.
Other than that, you were not entitled to a trial? They just confiscated everything and there it ended?
The manufacturer of the AC adapter didn't pay for testing, but put the mark on the adapter. The adapters weren't the main thing I was importing, so I hadn't paid any attention to it in the order process. The technical reason for the seizure was trademark violation.
Do you know what a trademark is? This wasn't a trademark violation, it was a fake certification.
The reason for the seizure is I don't want electronics in my house that could burn it down. UL cetifiies that. That's NOT a trademark. That's a certification.
You really don't seem to understand that you were caught trying to import bogus goods. It's also concerning that you are mixing up terms (trademark vs certification), as it casts doubt on the one side of the story I am hearing from you.
I get that it may not be your fault, but the CBP doesn't know that. They don't have a crystal ball to know that you were innocent of it, nor are they EEs who can figure out that's real and what's not. They also shouldn't be. Use a more trustworthy supplier next time.
I do understand the issues, and would not have sold products using those adapters knowing the UL mark was fake. The cost to get "real" adapters was a trivial portion of the overall cost.
However, that was NOT at all what the CBP was complaining about.
You bought bad goods from a bad supplier and got scammed. That's not the fault of the police.
While I'm not happy with the supplier, I don't think this was intentional on their part either. They just source AC adapters from someone else in Shenzhen. You can imagine they aren't real familiar with the consequences of trademark infringement. Which is what this was.
Edit: Note that it was all auctioned off later without the adapters. So the concept is known to them.
Also, see my friend's experience of a CD-ROM with a fake "Compact Disc" mark that resulted in a shipment of SBC's getting seized. Perhaps that one is more clear where the receiver wouldn't have any idea to even ask: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24469959
I will also hazard a guess that many HN folks have ordered things like generic arduinos, led blinky stuff, etc, and gotten an adapter with a fake UL mark. Smaller scale, but the same thing nonetheless.
So you were their first U.S. customer and they'd never shipped anything to the U.S. before?
I think I was just shipping during some customs frenzy to actually do something about it.
The first result for "Raspberry PI Power Supply" on Amazon for me, is this: https://www.amazon.com/NorthPada-Tinker-Supply-Charger-Adapt... I get similar results with other searches for adapters and power supplies.
It's a fake UL mark. The manufacturer isn't listed in UL's database, and a genuine UL mark would almost always have the UL listing number right below it.
There's also lots of adapters there with no UL or Intertek marks or testing.
If you can get the shipments split, I'm sure you could also get them to not send the power adapters at all. If, however, you needed power adapters, you need to import proper ones - not just for legal reasons, but for the safety of the end-users.
Separating the shipment is a relatively low cost way to protect the main item.
Edit: Another example that happened to a friend. He ordered some single board computers that came with some software on a CD...he wasn't even aware of the CD. The CD had a fake "Compact Disc" marking, which is a trademark. Whole shipment seized.
Why is it CBP/custom's job to enforce trademark law? I could just as easily print a fake logo in the US, but border control won't come after me - the people responsible for enforcing those laws will.
It seems you have absolutely no legal recourse here too, and it hurts American businesses. I know the US is far from libertarian, but this seems like overreach in the strangest way possible.
Edit: Regarding below, sure. But there are tons of unlisted adapters that come with electronics you might buy. I'd hazard a guess that most people have at least one in their house. Not that it's okay, just noting that it's common.
I don't think anyone cares about Intertek logos. /s
It seems pretty clear to me, I think you're missing the point of the post. It's that this person is protecting his business in a way that's effective because the government isn't, and this is what he's forced to do when dealing with agencies that claim they're looking out for his best interests.
After this happened I found that's pretty common. Not that it's okay, but there's tons of generic electronics on Amazon that come with adapters with a fake UL mark.
Edit: Regarding below. That never came up. It was all cited as a trademark issue.
Unknown to me, the AC adapters had fake UL marks on them. So, the CBP seized the shipment. I asked if they could just seize the adapters, and explained that I hadn't even asked for UL listed adapters. No dice. The adapters represented less than 10% of the value of the shipment. Argh.
And, of course, the Chinese supplier wasn't willing to reimburse me. Now I have the adapters go in a separate shipment in case something unexpected is shipped.