https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/8jbkgy/the_wra...
And the PCG author's response: https://www.pcg-random.org/posts/on-vignas-pcg-critique.html
For example, for one of his arguments, he specifically chose a generator called pcg32_once_insecure, which the PCG author does not recommend due to its invertible output function!
Personally, I have read both arguments in detail and I would always use PCG or even a truncated LCG over xoshiro, which has a large size in comparison, potentially worse statistical properties, and no gain- faster in some benchmarks and slower in others.
But I am using xoshiro in my projects, because I thought xor was simpler than multiplication.
But there exist some new and very fast PRNG's which are fast and extremely good. Almost TRNG, wyrand eg.
They recommend to use their xoshiro PRNG.