News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IGDA about the Amazon Android Appstore: just say no. by msy on Thursday April 14, 2011 @09:34AM (#2446742)
Say hello to the new boss, same as the old boss.

Amazon, Apple et al are becoming new middle men of the digital marketplace. Want to sell content online? If you want mass market exposure we'll have 30-70% of the revenue from the sweat of your brow and you better thank us for the privilege.

I wonder how long until they band together and form a lobby group called the Digital Content Providers Association of America.

Re:IGDA about the Amazon Android Appstore: just say no. by swombat on Thursday April 14, 2011 @11:43AM (#2447225)
And, like all middlemen, they very much deserve their cut.

What are you going to do with that pile of books in your cellar if there's no bookshop to sell them for you? Open your own single-book store?

If you build a store, you should certainly get a healthy cut of what you sell through your store.

Re:IGDA about the Amazon Android Appstore: just say no. by msy on Thursday April 14, 2011 @01:00PM (#2447555)
The problem isn't the existence of middle men, it's when oligopolies form that can bully producers and consumers alike and in the process stifle innovation and creativity.
Re:IGDA about the Amazon Android Appstore: just say no. by gyardley on Thursday April 14, 2011 @01:39PM (#2447713)
Of course middlemen deserve a healthy cut.

The issue here isn't whether Amazon deserves a cut, it's whether their incentives are aligned with the developers who use their platform. Amazon's control over pricing allows it to make decisions beneficial to the platform as a whole but potentially harmful to the individual developer.

Incentives are never going to be perfectly aligned, but letting the developer control pricing would make them a lot more aligned than they are now.

Re:IGDA about the Amazon Android Appstore: just say no. by Maascamp on Thursday April 14, 2011 @12:25PM (#2447409)
I certainly wouldn't generalize that to _ALL_ middle men. Have you heard about sub prime mortgages..?
Re:IGDA about the Amazon Android Appstore: just say no. by swombat on Thursday April 14, 2011 @12:45PM (#2447490)
Ok, probably not all. Let's say "many".
Re:IGDA about the Amazon Android Appstore: just say no. by Retric on Thursday April 14, 2011 @03:23PM (#2448060)
10% is a healthy cut 30% when they are not subsidizing the platform is a slap in the face. 30% and they get to restrict what you do with other platforms AND control your price structure is insane.

Under these terms you any developer that uses Amazon marketplace is stupid. They might make slightly more money in the sort term but you are giving up huge long term gains.

PS: I am seriously considering boycotting Amazon over this.

Re:IGDA about the Amazon Android Appstore: just say no. by cooldeal on Thursday April 14, 2011 @09:37AM (#2446748)
With Android atleast you can sell the app from your website or any market. With iPhone apps there is no chance of that at all. (Cydia doesn't really count).
Re:IGDA about the Amazon Android Appstore: just say no. by samatman on Thursday April 14, 2011 @01:21PM (#2447639)
Why doesn't Cydia count? I've never understood the logic here. Since the Supreme Court has determined that jailbreaking and alternate markets are legal, what does it matter that Apple would prefer you didn't install it?

But then, I've spent probably 30 bucks and counting on the Cydia store.

Re:IGDA about the Amazon Android Appstore: just say no. by irons on Thursday April 14, 2011 @04:02PM (#2448195)
The jailbreak ruling wasn't from the Supreme Court, it was from the US copyright office, which found that jailbreaking a smartphone was a legitimate exception to DMCA prohibitions on using technical means to beat copy protection.

The ruling means you can't be sued for jailbreaking. It doesn't give you a constitutional right to an unlocked phone, and it doesn't oblige Apple or AT&T or Google or HTC or whomever to support a jailbroken device. It certainly doesn't impair their ability to use technical measures (aka, fixing bugs) to impair your ability to jailbreak.

Since no one had ever been sued for jailbreaking (and similar policy was not applied to, for instance, the PS3), the practical effect of the copyright ruling was close to nil.

Re:IGDA about the Amazon Android Appstore: just say no. by CJefferson on Thursday April 14, 2011 @01:34PM (#2447697)
Cydia doesn't count because Apple keeps blocking holes which allow jailbreaking, so with new devices, there can be quite a long time period before you can get back into Cydia.
Re:IGDA about the Amazon Android Appstore: just say no. by GrandMasterBirt on Thursday April 14, 2011 @11:06AM (#2447084)
Yes but the problem is when markets hijack business models. Like what apple did with in-app sales.