News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Clone of the endangered Przewalski's horse is born of DNA... by akiselev on Sunday September 13, 2020 @02:24PM (#24462839)
> The colt is a clone of a male Przewalski's horse and the first successful cloning of the species, San Diego Zoo officials said in a news release on September 4. It was born August 6 to a domestic surrogate mother.

I just wanted to note how nonchalant this paragraph sounded in the context of the rest of the article. I remember the cloned sheep over a decade ago, but is animal cloning now so common a procedure that we've moved on from "Oh-em-gee, we cloned an animal!" to species bingo?

The DNA may have been perfectly preserved in lab conditions and we've got a sister species to carry the embryo so it's not comparable, but this is the first step to Jurassic park!

Re:Clone of the endangered Przewalski's horse is born of DNA... by bayesian_horse on Sunday September 13, 2020 @03:54PM (#24463456)
As far as I know, cloning is relatively "routine" now, especially in horses and other live stock, though relatively expensive. The main issue is that most clones don't survive to birth, so you need to repeat expensive procedures a lot of times.
Re:Clone of the endangered Przewalski's horse is born of DNA... by misnome on Sunday September 13, 2020 @02:37PM (#24462925)
> I remember the cloned sheep over a decade ago

Slightly out in your “remember a long time ago” - Dolly was born in 1996! Pet cloning apparently started in 2004! So it’s been around long enough to somewhat mature.

Re:Clone of the endangered Przewalski's horse is born of DNA... by akiselev on Sunday September 13, 2020 @02:43PM (#24462964)
I don't know what's more horrifying - how old that made me feel or that pet cloning is a thing. Marketwatch says it costs something like $50,000.

Of course there's been discussions on HN about it! [1][2]

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17723325

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16506712

Re:Clone of the endangered Przewalski's horse is born of DNA... by makx on Sunday September 13, 2020 @05:47PM (#24464195)
Thanks for sharing those links! This is so f*ed up that that's an industry. If all that money would have gone to preserving the wildlife we do still have left (but are losing rapidly)...
Re:Clone of the endangered Przewalski's horse is born of DNA... by kace91 on Sunday September 13, 2020 @05:48PM (#24464204)
I got confused reading your comment because I didn't expect you to refer to dolly as recent, it's from before I was able to read (and I'm about to enter my thirties).

It's funny how time is perceived differently by different people!

Re:Clone of the endangered Przewalski's horse is born of DNA... by nullsense on Monday September 14, 2020 @04:59AM (#24468173)
Re:Clone of the endangered Przewalski's horse is born of DNA... by microcolonel on Sunday September 13, 2020 @03:19PM (#24463202)
That's cool, I had no idea it'd gotten that inexpensive, I wonder how much cheaper it can get.
Re:Clone of the endangered Przewalski's horse is born of DNA... by tialaramex on Sunday September 13, 2020 @04:32PM (#24463751)
The most difficult trick isn't carrying it. We might plausibly one day achieve that synthetically. For any creatures whose parents stick around the parents provide essential cues for the offspring's behaviour. More complex behaviour is not "batteries included". Baby humans do not bootstrap a full-blown spoken (or signed) language, it's acquired from the other humans in their environment. A baby bird may be able to figure out how to fly but it definitely won't bootstrap all the detailed behaviour for its species if you don't provide parents to show how to be whatever sort of bird it is.

In this case we've got both a surrogate that's "close enough" as far as we're concerned, and also extant adult members of the species that Kurt will meet (and hopefully later breed with some of them) to cover anything we have no idea a Przewalski's horse is supposed to know about and wasn't handled by domestic horse behaviour.

But a baby dinosaur has nobody to show it how to be whatever sort of dinosaur it is. We could teach it to be what we thought it was supposed to be, but we have no idea if we're right!

Re:Clone of the endangered Przewalski's horse is born of DNA... by ampdepolymerase on Sunday September 13, 2020 @05:31PM (#24464107)
Doesn't matter in practice if you are really trying to re-create Jurrasic Park. A working dinosaur is already useful for monetisation, even if Hollywood's idea of what dinosaurs should be like does not quite match up to reality.