So, what books did you find? Why not make a post on your method?
I posted the books in this thread (sorry, on mobile right now).
That said, I can see value in providing a score not just in the items, but on the ranking system used. Could even be adaptive based on genre. (Indeed, I would love a system to see if any books have factual errors and such. But, that is just trying to reinvent the citation systems of academia.)
And understood on the mobile. Same boat for me.
Easier to think of this from the other side. I have a few friends that, if they tell me to avoid something, it can typically override however popular something may be.
EG "best average" "most reviewed" "users in country + frequency" and such.
This doesn't even need to hit performance, as these queries could all run on a secondary SQL server, be cached in redis/whatever once an hour, or even day.
After all, this sort of list output doesn't need to be second by second changing.
So simple to implement, non-performance impacting, which makes it even more curious as to 'why not'. Likely, a UI/UX person thinks it will 'confuse' people.
(I know that may not be the case, but it seems to kill more sites, and more flexible functionality, than anything...)
Suggestions: The Sot-Weed Factor, Gravity’s Rainbow, Mason & Dixon, Underworld, and if you’re feeling particularly masochistic The Tunnel
https://github.com/johnfn/GoodReadsScraper
Particularly, load bigdata.js into nodejs and then run a command sort of like this to parse out the results, filtering out young adult/romance/religion stuff/comics:
bigdata.filter(f => f.ratings > 5000 && !f.genres.includes('Young Adult') && !f.genres.includes('Religion') && !f.genres.includes('Romance') && !f.genres.includes('Sequential Art')).map(f => f.title)
I get some pretty interesting stuff. First result is the Constitution... OK, fair enough... but the next 10 or so are: 'A Song of Ice and Fire',
'Collected Fictions', (by Borges)
'The Name of the Wind',
'Infinite Jest',
'The Complete Works',
'The Way of Kings',
'The Wise Man\'s Fear',
'Ficciones',
'A Storm of Swords: Blood and Gold',
'The Complete Stories',
'Labyrinths',
'Don\'t Let the Pigeon Drive the Bus!',
'The Hiding Place',
Is it an amazing list? Eh. Is Name of the Wind better than Infinite Jest? Probably not. They're both fantastic books, though! And still, it's way better than Listopia. Also, this data is 8 years old. I bet it would be way better if I were to clean it up and run it in 2020.
So you don’t think I’m all talk, a while back I got so fed up with this that I wrote my own script to scrape goodreads and find the actual best books, not just the most popular, and I found a wealth of really good and unknown books, including two books that are now my favorite books of all time. It was a side project that took me an hour. Why goodreads can’t do this is utterly beyond me.
Aaaargh!!!