News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Another Way to View the "Decline" of HN by carussell on Wednesday April 13, 2011 @10:21PM (#2445255)
Okay, point taken. But now ask yourself whether the following are things that you're looking for in the "software business" forum you describe:

advertising, or "SEO" in various guises, people selling their useless web app, pushing their own affiliate links, breathless chortling over the lastest gray areas to investigate for reducing their taxes, or promoting their own blog

Re:Another Way to View the "Decline" of HN by roel_v on Thursday April 14, 2011 @03:34AM (#2445985)
- advertising: yes (I'm assuming this is 'how to do advertising', not 'advertising for someone else's product)

- SEO: yes (same)

- people selling useless web app: this is just how you look at it; in many cases, it's people who want feedback on their experimental ideas. Which I think is fine.

- ppl pushing affiliate links: no, but they didn't used to be here, either

- tax optimisation: yes

- blog promotion: as long as they're blogs on the topics of the forum, yes

Many things on the list are described in a negative way, so it's only natural that they're undesirable. But I don't see them that often (like affiliate links - they're quite rare as far as I can tell) and I used to think that Youtube was useless, too.