News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wildlife in ‘catastrophic decline’ due to human destructi... by atweiden on Friday September 11, 2020 @11:40PM (#24449628)
> The unfortunate reality is that mankind as we know it, probably developed to the level it did, in part due to the consumption of meat.

Hedging language aside — i.e. "humans evolved because X to some extent" — I recently had an epiphany touring the north island of New Zealand by minibus. Productivity utterly collapses when you have to frequently move from one (temporary) settlement to another. What you eat isn't nearly as impactful as the degree to which you can be stationary.

Interestingly, primitive hunter-gatherer societies could rely upon wild game or fish for caloric intake, which was conducive to a nomadic life. There's no need for an agricultural revolution if you're OK with killing wild animals to harvest their flesh for food. But to call this instrumental in human development is I think wrong. Meat is without question the most primitive way to feed: meat consumption does not require any amount of long-term settlement nor does it require much intelligence: carnivorous animals low in general intelligence regularly kill each other in the wild for food.

Meat consumption is fundamentally a primitive adaptation. Factory farmed meat consumption is a relatively modern phenomenon driven first and foremost by human habituation to the taste of flesh. Plants can provide every nutrient required for human survival save for vitamin B12.

> Meat is absolutely PACKED with bioavailable nutrients in a way that most plant products simply aren't.

Such as? Meat is a euphemism for slabs of fat and muscle tissue containing amino acids. With the exception of wild-caught fatty fish like salmon — factory farmed fatty fish contain greatly reduced levels of omega-3s — the fat is of questionable healthiness compared to vegetable sources. And if you're convinced it's necessary to consume the muscle tissue of formerly living creatures for amino acids, you'd eat insects for environmental sustainability's sake. In fact, insect exoskeletons are a rich source of dietary calcium directly comparable to dairy. The fact most of you reading this wouldn't dream of eating insects, goes to show nutritional value is not why you're eating meat. Taste is #1.

> Add to that, the growing evidence that much of the plant material we're eating may have inflammatory side effects of consumption.

Citation needed.

> The point I am making is that a solution isn't a solution if it means getting rid of one of the most dense forms of nutrition we have.

Where do high-fat nuts and seeds fit in your view of "dense forms of nutrition"? E.g. gram for gram, you're getting much more calories from nuts and seeds than you're getting from low-fat muscle tissue such as chicken.

Re:Wildlife in ‘catastrophic decline’ due to human destructi... by toxik on Saturday September 12, 2020 @03:32AM (#24450638)
What a ridiculous hot take. We buy meat to have a varied and healthy diet, and yes we like our food to taste good - as is that is something to be ashamed of?

We don’t buy insects because last time I checked, supermarkets don’t sell them. Maybe you could look into why time and time again, insect food startups fail.

Re:Wildlife in ‘catastrophic decline’ due to human destructi... by atweiden on Saturday September 12, 2020 @06:41AM (#24451461)
I'm not here to be your enemy, so please don't make me out to be one. I wasn't raised vegetarian by any means, and I know fully well meat tastes amazingly good, and that having a varied diet is important. But heart disease, diabetes and many types of cancers are worryingly linked with the consumption of meat, dairy and eggs. As the documentary Forks Over Knives [1] makes abundantly clear, a whole foods plant-based diet is in every way a life extension technology.

> Is that something to be ashamed of?

Wanting to feel satiated is nothing to be ashamed of. What is arguably shameful, however, is how the bacon gets made [2].

[1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YtnlwqEii2I

[2]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LQRAfJyEsko

Re:Wildlife in ‘catastrophic decline’ due to human destructi... by CamperBob2 on Saturday September 12, 2020 @05:40PM (#24456049)
But heart disease, diabetes and many types of cancers are diseases that you will get, regardless of diet or lifestyle, if nothing else kills you first.
Re:Wildlife in ‘catastrophic decline’ due to human destructi... by seanwilson on Saturday September 12, 2020 @06:28PM (#24456423)
This part is more of a reply to people claiming meat is the natural thing to eat so it must be healthy, it's what we've eaten for centuries, you can't be healthy without eating meat etc.

Nobody is arguing that taste isn't important but are your current taste preferences more important than climate change and animal suffering?

Re:Wildlife in ‘catastrophic decline’ due to human destructi... by CamperBob2 on Saturday September 12, 2020 @07:53PM (#24456952)
Nobody is arguing that taste isn't important but are your current taste preferences more important than climate change

No, but synthmeat will largely take care of that aspect of the problem. Not as soon as we'd like, but we'll get there.

and animal suffering?

To the extent animals are suffering, I'd encourage you to get involved legislatively. Contact your representatives, and support organizations that work for change (ethically, which excludes PETA). Animal abuse is unnecessary and unlike climate change, it can be stopped, right now, if people speak up.

Re:Wildlife in ‘catastrophic decline’ due to human destructi... by bamboozled on Friday September 11, 2020 @11:49PM (#24449665)
“Plants can provide every nutrient required for human survival save for vitamin B12.”

Which is what’s interesting to me, you basically cannot actually be vegan without supplements. Maybe this is where we should go as a specifies for ethical reasons.

But it’s a mental leap to rely on supplements for vital nutrients.

Re:Wildlife in ‘catastrophic decline’ due to human destructi... by ncmncm on Saturday September 12, 2020 @12:09AM (#24449776)
All of the B12 consumed anywhere in the world -- and all animals need it -- comes exclusively from bacteria. The bacteria in your colon produce thousands of times as much as you need, but you do not absorb so much as a nanogram of it. (Dogs and rabbits eat their own crap to get it.)

The process for absorbing B12, in the upper intestine, is the most intricate of any vitamin, starting with saliva. Apparently the huge variety of almost-B12 variants have to be filtered out, so as not to gum up the works.

It is common for Americans (and maybe others?) over 50 to develop an autoimmune reaction to some part of the process, and lose most ability to absorb B12. (You may notice shooting pains in your arms if you get this.) Then you need to take 5mg daily supplements. The micrograms in meat and dairy are then not enough.

So, if you think you are eating meat for the B12, surprise! that is not where it comes from. Homo erectus probably got enough from the dirt on everything, and grubs.

Re:Wildlife in ‘catastrophic decline’ due to human destructi... by pvaldes on Saturday September 12, 2020 @02:52PM (#24454529)
> Homo erectus probably got enough from the dirt on everything, and grubs

And now they are extinct. It seems that the plan didn't worked very well.

The faster way to ingest lots and lots of bacteria so you don't die is a simple one: Carrion. Our ancestors ate as much as they could find. The other monkeys are dead (and our plant eaters relatives are almost extinct).

Re:Wildlife in ‘catastrophic decline’ due to human destructi... by ncmncm on Saturday September 12, 2020 @05:43PM (#24456082)
You are descended from Homo Erectus. They survived for many times longer than H. sap has, and it is far from clear that we will outlast them, in the end.

Eat carrion if you like. I will send flowers to your grave.

Re:Wildlife in ‘catastrophic decline’ due to human destructi... by pvaldes on Saturday September 12, 2020 @06:32PM (#24456450)
> Eat carrion if you like.

I don't need to, animals have plenty of vitamin B12, but I could do if necessary of course, because my species is omnivore. Better than ignoring my real nature and being forced to eat dirt or my own crap to fix my diet.

> I will send flowers to your grave.

Can't fall to mention that is a nice detail. Will be appreciated.

Re:Wildlife in ‘catastrophic decline’ due to human destructi... by ncmncm on Thursday September 17, 2020 @03:08PM (#24508654)
> Will be appreciated.

You will be dead, and not equipped to appreciate anything.

Re:Wildlife in ‘catastrophic decline’ due to human destructi... by seanwilson on Friday September 11, 2020 @11:51PM (#24449684)
B12 usually comes from bacteria in soil (and not meat directly) that we don't get now because of cleaner vegetables and cleaner water. Likewise, many industrial animals kept indoors won't get as much B12, so that's why they're given B12 supplements. If you avoid meat, you can just take B12 supplements directly instead of them being filtered through an animal first. If you think this sounds "unnatural", there's nothing natural about intensive animal farming which is where most people get their meat from.
Re:Wildlife in ‘catastrophic decline’ due to human destructi... by drewm1980 on Saturday September 12, 2020 @12:10AM (#24449783)
We used to get B12 from bacteria in the soil, but these days we clean our food immaculately, and we're also ruining our soil. My understanding is that B12 deficiency is a potential problem for everyone; vegan diets are just under more scrutiny. Also, the whole notion of "supplements" is not very useful; it's all just food. I don't know how B12 is produced, but if they're growing it by culturing the same bacteria we used to get B12 from, we have only industrialized the same symbiotic relationship we already had with certain microbes.
Re:Wildlife in ‘catastrophic decline’ due to human destructi... by atweiden on Saturday September 12, 2020 @12:00AM (#24449740)
My B12 supplement is derived from plant sources, which I find far preferable to secondary B12 consumption from injected grain-fed animal tissue which is the modern status quo.

[1]: https://www.gardenoflife.com/content/product/mykind-organics...

Re:Wildlife in ‘catastrophic decline’ due to human destructi... by ncmncm on Saturday September 12, 2020 @12:14AM (#24449798)
There are exactly zero plant sources of B12. Or animal sources, either.

100.0000% of B12, anywhere in the world, comes from bacteria.