News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jeff Bezos's gain during Covid is enough to give all his ... by ryan_h on Friday September 11, 2020 @06:55PM (#24448169)
Holding an asset does not result in a capital gain. The Tax the Billionaires bill wants to tax holding an asset that has appreciated in value. Not only that, but they use a handpicked time boundary that from the bottom of the market crash to calculate a windfall tax.

Lets say you owned 1 BTC since the inception ($0 cost basis) and held it until today. The value of 1 BTC has fluctuated the entire time, but you've only ever owned 1BTC.

Here are a couple lows/highs during the period: Dec 2018 - $3500 Jun 2019 - $12000 $8500 gain (on paper)

March 2020 - $5500 Aug 2020 - $12000 $6500 gain (on paper)

To use the Bernie Sanders standard of 60% windfall gains, you'd owe $5100 from the 2018 crash and recovery. If these types of windfall taxes become a common thing, you'd owe an additional $3,900 from the 2020 crash and recovery. So you'd have paid $9,000 to hold your 1BTC.

If you sell your 1BTC today, you'd get $10,000. With your $0 cost basis, the entire $10,000 is a capital gain. Lets say your long term capital gains rate is 15%, you'd owe $1,500 in taxes when you sell it.

So for investing in 1 BTC, you'd have $8500 in your bank account, and would have paid $10,500 to hold it.

1) Is BTC more volatile than Amazon stock: Yes 2) Does that amplify the numbers in my example: Yes 3) Is wealth inequality a giant problem in the country: Yes 4) Will I shed tears if Jeff Bezos gets a giant tax bill in the mail: No

However, I think it does demonstrate the problem with taxing the change in value of an asset, vs your capital gain from when you sell it.

There are no comments on this comment yet.