Re:The lack of namespaces on crates.io is a feature
by kibwen on Friday September 11, 2020 @01:58PM
(#24445454)
That's a better rationale, although I don't think that really solves your stated problem; as an uninformed user I am still more likely to think that iglu/iglu is the more authoritative source there. Given this, any project that wants to authoritatively own its identifier should probably also register its own top-level namespace... which unfortunately brings us back around to where we started.
Re:The lack of namespaces on crates.io is a feature
by gw on Friday September 11, 2020 @02:52PM
(#24446083)
It would at least be far less of an issue. I don't see anyone being confused that https://github.com/facebook/react is the official repo, and not https://github.com/react/react. It's the fact that a collapsed name is a shortcut that imbues it with this special stature. And i believe maven central doesn't even allow one-segment group names for new libraries, though clojars obviously does.
Another point i didn't mention is that maven was designed from the start to be decentralized; many companies run their own private maven repos, but also pull artifacts from maven central. Having group names reduces the chances of collisions between their private servers and a public maven server.