News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Security by obscurity is underrated by 3pt14159 on Friday September 11, 2020 @12:54PM (#24444699)
In DC there is this concept of "the blob" which is basically shorthand for "The Washington consensus that isn't verifiable, but that most people parrot since to hold an opposing view doesn't really get you anything because even if you're right, nobody will remember. All that they'll remember is that you're that weird guy that looks at stuff with a strange perspective and that you may be too dense to social signal that you're in the blob."

I've noticed the same thing with software developers.

- "Client side encryption in JavaScript is useless!" Until CloudBleed came out and the only company that was safe was a password manager that used it. To thwart client side encryption you need to actually modify the contents of the JS payload, which is detectable. But no matter how much evidence I give that this tactic works and is actually used in production and that it actually stops attacks, programmers just don't care.

- "Don't do security by obscurity!" But then we all implement passwords (which is just security by obscurity) and the best people in intelligence don't have LinkedIn accounts. Anyone can join an OSINT forum and see the actual tools that get used. Security by obscurity works for many, many actors.

There are many, many little bits of stuff like this. Think to yourself: How many times has code that you've written lead to an RCE vuln that was exploited. Personally, I can only give a lower bound, and that lower bound is zero because I'm extremely careful, but I don't pretend that it's never happened. Anyone that is familiar with data science or economics or political economy understands that when a signal is dampened the response is dampened.

Re:Security by obscurity is underrated by josephcsible on Friday September 11, 2020 @01:14PM (#24444940)
> But then we all implement passwords (which is just security by obscurity)

No it isn't. Security by obscurity is explicitly keeping things other than passwords and keys secret.

Re:Security by obscurity is underrated by oh_sigh on Friday September 11, 2020 @02:07PM (#24445555)
That is not the definition at all. If I kept track of my passwords by making them the first letter of each page of various books on my bookshelves, that would be security through obscurity, because, while if someone who broke into my home knew about my system, it would be quite easy to extract all my passwords, but if they didn't know about my system, they would be looking forever for a notebook with cryptic letters in it, or sticky notes on the monitor, etc.
Re:Security by obscurity is underrated by Spivak on Friday September 11, 2020 @01:27PM (#24445112)
I feel like it's a pretty weak point to say that passwords and keys would be security by obscurity if we didn't carve out a special exception for them. Why do they get a special exception? Because they're really really hard to guess, not because they're fundamentally different.

Let me give a real-life example of a good non-password, non-key piece of secret information that's used for authentication. If you need to recover a WoW account that you've lost access to the customer service reps will ask you to tell them the names of the characters on the account. Your account name isn't secret, and your character names aren't secret. But the relationship is because they aren't ever publicly connected. The odds that someone other than the account owner having this information is low and the odds of guessing it by chance is impossible.

Re:Security by obscurity is underrated by hannasanarion on Friday September 11, 2020 @01:57PM (#24445451)
Security by obscurity refers to obscuring the design of a system, not obscuring credentials.

Hiding your password isn't security through obscurity. Hiding the fact that you need to say a password to get into a building is.

Protecting your encryption keys isn't security through obscurity. Hiding which encryption algorithm you are using is.

Re:Security by obscurity is underrated by floe on Friday September 11, 2020 @01:35PM (#24445207)
They're verifiably hard to guess. That is fundamentally different.

(At least when passwords are generated with enough entropy.)

Re:Security by obscurity is underrated by Spivak on Friday September 11, 2020 @01:53PM (#24445400)
But does that make them different or are they just things that are easy to verify? If you could calculate the entropy of another authentication scheme would it be included?

The danger of security by obscurity is that your system might not have as much entropy as you initially estimate and can be easily defeated. Sounds a lot like the vulnerabilities in normal crypo applications, right?

Re:Security by obscurity is underrated by saagarjha on Friday September 11, 2020 @01:57PM (#24445452)
Except this is the kind of thing that you can get around if you know the person and/or the account.
Re:Security by obscurity is underrated by Spivak on Friday September 11, 2020 @01:14PM (#24444933)
> "Don't do security by obscurity!" But then we all implement passwords (which is just security by obscurity)

Thank you for being someone else who recognizes this. If having a secret piece of knowledge grants you access to the system then it's obscurity. Once we admit that then we can start talking about the difficulty of guessing that knowledge as the actual important factor.

Re:Security by obscurity is underrated by jlgaddis on Friday September 11, 2020 @01:31PM (#24445159)
> If having a [password] grants you access to the system then it's obscurity.

Perhaps if you're hiding it under the doormat in front of the door and expecting it won't be found. Or writing your PIN on your ATM card with a sharpie and leaving it on the dash of your car with the doors unlocked and your windows down.

In most cases, however, it's part of an overall system that involves authentication, authorization, and (hopefully!) accounting to protect access to resources.