Re:Exploring new forms of chess using artificial intelligence
by shmageggy on Friday September 11, 2020 @05:32PM
(#24447539)
I think it's an imprecise way of saying that AlphaZero isn't given the game rules, so it doesn't know the difference between legal and illegal moves, and also that before any training it would evaluate a caputure no differently than any other move.
Re:Exploring new forms of chess using artificial intelligence
by floe on Friday September 11, 2020 @07:18PM
(#24448350)
> isn't given the game rules, so it doesn't know the difference between legal and illegal moves
But it does have some way to determine a list of legal moves from any given state, and a way to determine whether a state is winning. To me, that's being 'given the game rules'.
> before any training it would evaluate a capture no differently than any other move.
That's a good way to say it!
'doesn’t know it can take an opponent’s pieces' - really? How would the world be different if it did 'know'?
I know this is kind of a nitpick, but I'm tired of all the metaphors in tech journalism that hold no informational value. I think giving a sense of false understanding is worse than just saying nothing at all.