Re:Radio Engineer Files Objection to WIPE
by anon9001 on Friday September 11, 2020 @12:15PM
(#24444324)
> why should I tolerate a special exception for THESE people to broadcast data
The problem is it's not about you or me tolerating the special exception or not. It's about recourse, and we have none.
> a new exemption for these people just because they have money
The people with money can donate to all the politicians and make them aware of their needs, in exchange for the donations continuing. That's their recourse.
> This should not be understood as an infight by HFTs.
But that's exactly what it is. Multiple entities with money lobbying the same government for favorable results.
Re:Radio Engineer Files Objection to WIPE
by kd0amg on Friday September 11, 2020 @12:35PM
(#24444508)
Yes, the active parties in the fight are two HFTs jockeying for latency advantage, but the scope of the fight goes beyond HFT: they are fighting over use of a scarce public resource.
Re:Radio Engineer Files Objection to WIPE
by smkellat on Friday September 11, 2020 @12:29PM
(#24444447)
As Glenn Hauser, Kim Andrew Elliott, and others have asked it comes down to the big question of what regs exactly authorize this. There really isn’t any ambiguity in the relevant rules to sneak this in under.
Even if I saw HFT as a valuable thing (I don't), it's unfair to create a new exemption for these people just because they have money. And if you suggest that he government shouldn't be involved, then keep in mind the only practical force stopping someone from jamming these transmissions is the exact same government bandwidth allocation guidelines.
This should not be understood as an infight by HFTs. It should be understood as the radio waves of the world being a public, shared resource and folks asking, "Are we changing these rules now?" If so, it should be done equitably.