Re:What Clojure Spec is and what you can do with it
by jwr on Thursday September 10, 2020 @03:58PM
(#24435961)
Yes, that was largely my point. Many people (me included) assume that s/conform is a kind of coercion, which it is not.
Not all of the above problems are due to coercion, but the majority are.
To be clear: I'm not complaining here, I find spec to be very useful and I like it, just pointing out traps for the unwary.
Re:What Clojure Spec is and what you can do with it
by didibus on Friday September 11, 2020 @12:44PM
(#24444585)
Ya fair enough, I've definitely seen a lot of people think conforming is meant for coercion. But it's not, it's only meant for disambiguating the chosen path (when multiple are possible) for validation.
Re:What Clojure Spec is and what you can do with it
by zcam on Friday September 11, 2020 @12:36AM
(#24439239)
There are a few libraries that make it possible without abusing conformers, one of which is https://github.com/exoscale/coax
Conformers are meant to parse the data when there are multiple possibility of what something can validate against, the conformer will disambiguate and return a result that tells you which path was chosen.
Coercion is not supported as part of Spec, you're expected to do that seperatly either before or after validating/conforming.