> 34.10.040 Exceptions.
> The prohibition in this Chapter does not apply to use of Face Recognition Technologies:
> A. To the extent necessary for a Private Entity to comply with federal, state, or local laws;
> B. For user verification purposes by an individual to access the individual’s own personal or employer issued communication and electronic devices; or
> C. In automatic face detection services in social media applications. [1]
That seems like it would include what Facebook is doing -- but the ordinance never defines a "social media application" and also uses face detection and face recognition interchangeably in some places, so it's hard to say for sure what it allows.
[1] https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5967c18bff7c50a0244ff...
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/18/technology/clearview-priv...
This law could certainly use more clarity.
Also, the definition excludes the face blurring use case. "'Face Recognition' means the automated searching for a reference image in an image repository." Although that detail does mean that if you're not searching for "a reference image" then you would technically be clear of the law's restriction. What if you build features based on a reference image then delete the image? Or what if what you're searching for is a person and the image is not the search target?
That I suspect would take more effort to parse. But the penalties are pretty light and the provable damages done by facial recognition are pretty minor, so if organizations get a lot of value out of facial recognition then they might want to try rolling the dice.
Any reasonable interpertation would find that the representation used during search doesn't affect what is happening.
Searching for text uses a TF-IDF or BM25 representation.
The only way to make image search work is to use a non-pixel representation. No court will find you aren't searching for an image because of that.
Maybe I'm wrong though. IANAL and honestly it doesn't matter. But if I were writing this law, I would write that no one would be allowed to use any system that extracts and searches using or makes searchable information about human faces. That would seem to cover my proposed workaround, and I doubt it would hurt any other use case that they meant to protect.
It's pretty clear that isn't banned. See point 6 in the explanation:
6.Face Recognition means the automated searching for a reference image in an image repository by comparing the facial features of a probe image with the features of images contained in an image repository (one-to-many search). A Face Recognition search will typically result in one or more most likely candidates—or candidate images—ranked by computer-evaluated similarity or will return a negative result.
It is written to outlaw recognition (ie, the search action), NOT detection.
Then it's not illegal. Portland's jurisdiction only extends to the borders of Portland. Even when it makes logical sense, you can't have agencies in Portland exercising executive control over organizations and people that don't live there. That way lies madness.
But it's a pretty easy loophole to close - just make it illegal to share images of people in public in Portland for the purposes of facial recognition. Now you can keep sharing images the way you used to, but it's a huge liability to try to do this to skirt the law.
At the end of the day if someone really wants to use facial recognition on (against?) someone in Portland, there are legal ways to do it even with explicit prohibitions like this. And the more nefarious the actors, the more likely they'll just use an illegal way.
So for an entity present in Portland they cannot run facial recognition in a public place in Portland. But what if entity A is partnered with entity B. Entity B procures images of people in public in Portland city limits and places them on a server in another state. Entity A, which is conveniently headquartered elsewhere takes the data from the server and runs facial recognition. This is clearly facial recognition of persons in public in Portland. But it’s not by a Portland business and the computing isn’t done in Portland either.