News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Elvish is a friendly interactive shell and an expressive ... by xiaq on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @09:34PM (#24428006)
Elvish and PowerShell shares one big thing: let command outputs carry structured value. Everything else is quite different:

* Elvish is a more minimalist language influenced by the Lisp tradition, whereas PowerShell is a much larger language with its own distinct "flavor" (in a good way; the language has some quirks but seems decent overall).

* PowerShell has a lot of integration with the .NET ecosystem and Windows APIs. Elvish obviously has none of those.

* Elvish has a pretty sophisticated UI, whereas PowerShell seems to lag behind a bit in UI features.

Getting back to philosophy, it seems to me that the development PowerShell is largely driven by facilitating common Windows sysadmin tasks, and the team seems to have some very concrete use cases in mind.

On the other hand, the design of Elvish has two main tenets, one theoretical and one practical: make a good programming language that is still "shell like", and make a powerful flexible UI suitable for daily use.

Re:Elvish is a friendly interactive shell and an expressive ... by andreareina on Thursday September 10, 2020 @12:12AM (#24428819)
> Elvish is a more minimalist language influenced by the Lisp tradition, whereas PowerShell is a much larger language with its own distinct "flavor" (in a good way; the language has some quirks but seems decent overall).

Could you expand on what you mean by this? It sounds like you're conflating the size of the language with some measure of lispiness, but Common Lisp for example is huge.

Re:Elvish is a friendly interactive shell and an expressive ... by garmaine on Thursday September 10, 2020 @01:37AM (#24429206)
It's confusing to me that you don't consider LISP to be a simple/minimalist language.

Core language, not standard library, extensions, etc.

Re:Elvish is a friendly interactive shell and an expressive ... by dunefox on Thursday September 10, 2020 @04:39AM (#24430173)
Simplicity of core language and syntax does not necessarily translate into simplicity of the language, see Common Lisp.